2 ms·
Incidentally, I think it should be illegal for any public official to send his/her child to private school or to receive care in a private hospital. We have un
by btilly 17y ago
Incidentally, I think it should be illegal for any public official to send his/her child to private school or to receive care in a private hospital.
We have unexpected agreement on that.
On the rest, my experience of Canada says that the culture is not very different than the USA. The political culture does have some significant differences, but the people are more similar than not. If education works better in Canada than it does in the USA (my experience and international comparisons suggest that it does), then it can work better in the USA as well.
On the religious point, that may be a real factor in the difference. I ran across the one figure in The Homework Myth but don't have the level of detail to break down private schools by type. Another factor that I suspect is that there is a large gap between the factors that parents will see as quality, and factors that actually affect student learning. Private schools that offer a lot of extracurriculars and make good presentations to parents will attract investment, whether or not the students are truly getting a quality education.
Personally if I could afford to, I would sidestep the whole mess and home-school. But that is not in the cards any time soon. :-(
- grandalf 17y agoInteresting. I'd be curious if perhaps other industries/services are better in Canada... for example, restaurant service, accounting services, etc. There could simply be an aspect of the supply of qualified labor -- if Canada has 5% greater supply of qualified workers for a given position, then some of them will have to work in a job that is beneath them, in which they will overperform. Canada generally has a slightly higher unemployment rate than the US, so arguably this results in some degree of labor under-utilization and overperformance... this may be the case with Canadian teachers and could be enough to explain the superiority. I think your point about the varying attributes of private schools is quite insightful. I don't necessarily think it's a bad thing, considering how much rote memorization of facts I was put through in the name of "education". I still don't know what I would do to educate a child. I think home schooling would be very difficult to do well, and I do idealize some of the best (public and private) school environments...