3 ms·
>But how am I supposed to enjoy a holiday when my journey starts with my other half and me being virtual-strip-searched by sometimes dubious characters we can't
by foldr 17y ago
>But how am I supposed to enjoy a holiday when my journey starts with my other half and me being virtual-strip-searched by sometimes dubious characters we can't even see and ends with having biometric scans taken to go into a database as if I were a criminal?
Just enjoy the bit in the middle.
- Silhouette 17y agoIs that the part where I have to take off half my clothes for real so they can put the belt and jacket outside the metal detector and the shoes through whatever that other machines does, the bit where they throw away the bottle of soda I was enjoying and make me buy a new one, the bit where someone glares at me over the top of my passport while heavily armed guards look on, the bit where the staff on the way onto the plane mess several passengers around because they don't like their tone and have a "zero tolerance" policy, the bit at the other end where I queue up for ages only to again have someone glare at me over the top of my passport in the presence of armed guards, or something else?
- foldr 17y agoReally, don't be such a drama queen. Airport security isn't fun, but you're being silly about it. (And no, by "the bit in the middle", I meant the holiday.)
- Silhouette 17y agoIn the past year alone, several of my friends have been literally strip searched (not just the virtual one) for no apparent reason. Sure, some people don't care about being seen naked, but a lot of people do and this is a deeply embarrassing and unpleasant experience that will stay with them for a long time. Members of my family have been left stranded in a foreign country when an airline refused to carry them because one of them asked why he was required to show the same documents for the third time in rapid succession. (The airline's excuse for this absurdly disproportionate response changed so many times afterwards it was hard to keep track, and I won't say any more because as far as I'm aware legal action for compensation is still pending.) Hundreds of people from my country have recently been held in hotels under armed guard because after a diversion to a different country's airport due to the ash problems, they obviously didn't have visas, so they couldn't even get a train home. I'm not sure why anyone in a country these people never wanted or expected to visit would consider them such a security threat that they couldn't leave and had to be held at gunpoint, but there you go. These things are not trivial, and I don't think a single one of those people would consider objecting to this sort of security theatre "being silly". And you fail on the "bit in the middle", because all the unpleasantness that I described in those earlier posts happens on a single flight.
- foldr 17y ago>And you fail on the "bit in the middle", because all the unpleasantness that I described in those earlier posts happens on a single flight. You were talking about the start and the end of the journey in your OP. I assumed the "end" part referred to the return flight. Hence the holiday would be "the bit in the middle". I'm know that people have bad experiences sometimes, but you're making an absurdly huge drama out of it. Refusing to fly is simply not a reasonable response to the typical level of inconvenience. >Hundreds of people from my country have recently been held in hotels under armed guard This has nothing to do with airport security, but rather immigration policy. You're going off on so many tangents here I'm not really sure what to say.
- Silhouette 17y ago> I'm know that people have bad experiences sometimes, but you're making an absurdly huge drama out of it. The point is that almost everyone I know seems to be having a bad experience with flying these days, and almost all of it is directly due to the over-zealous security and related issues. Why should we "come quietly" and accept our quality of life being reduced in this way? > Refusing to fly is simply not a reasonable response to the typical level of inconvenience. I, and an increasing number of my friends and family, disagree with you. Fortunately, where and how we travel still remains our choice, so those modes of transport and destinations that offer a pleasant, efficient experience will benefit, while those that do not will suffer.
- Zev 17y agoThe point is that almost everyone I know seems to be having a bad experience with flying these days Just as a counterpoint, almost everyone I know is minorly inconvenienced and continues on their merry way way when flying. Mainly grumbling about having to repack their carry-on and security theater jokes. And these are people flying into/out of major airports (SFO, LAX, JFK, ORD to name a few). // edit: Include me in this as well. And I've flown into or out of ROC, JFK and SFO ~8-10x a year (4-5 trips a year) for the past 3 years. Of course, this just illustrates anecdotes and that people view things differently. Shocking, I know. Hundreds of people from my country Out of curiosity, just what country are you from? Or your family? You haven't said. At least, not that I've noticed.
- logic 17y agoThis is the conversational equivalent of "your feelings on the matter are irrelevant; suck it up, because I don't think it's so bad". Your opinion is duly noted. For what it's worth, I haven't flown in over a year and a half, and have no intention of doing so until airport security returns to some semblance of sanity. I'm not being a "drama queen" about it; I simply won't pay an exorbitant rate for the privilege of being treated as a criminal because I'd like to board an airplane.
- foldr 17y ago> I'm not being a "drama queen" about it; I simply won't pay an exorbitant rate for the privilege of being treated as a criminal because I'd like to board an airplane. So, you don't think your second clause there has event a hint of hyperbole?
- logic 17y agoNot at all. The last few times I've flown (US to Canada and back again), I walked away from the experience feeling abused by the U.S. side of the transaction. You can choose to accept that or not, and can certainly write off my opinion as hyperbole if you'd like; that's your prerogative. But I don't believe I'm the only one who feels that way. (If the "exorbitant rate" portion is what you object to, see my reply elsewhere in the thread.)
- stcredzero 17y agothe bit where someone glares at me over the top of my passport while heavily armed guards look on The experience of the Israeli authorities, is that doing this works. You have to do this 7 times to get through the airport in Israel. They can also do it quickly and efficiently.
- alanh 17y agoPractical short-term self-help advice, but irrelevant to this political debate. Troll?
- foldr 17y agoThe OP seemed to be seriously suggesting that aiport security is so bad that he wouldn't consider flying to a foreign country for a holiday. I agree that aiport security is a bit of a farce. But hysteria of this sort doesn't contribute much to the political debate either. I'm not sure that providing practical self-help advice ought to count as trolling, anyway. HN isn't meant to be a political forum. Strictly speaking, any political debate is OT here.
- Silhouette 17y ago> But hysteria of this sort doesn't contribute much to the political debate either. It's not hysteria, it's fact. I personally will not fly to many destinations now, because the unpleasantness and inefficiency mean it is not worth the effort. I have been finding out recently that several of my friends and family now share this view, so I'm certainly not an isolated case. For comparison, I will happily travel between London and Europe via Eurostar to Paris, where the equivalent checks required about five minutes and nothing particularly onerous or unpleasant, and in fact the staff were friendly and helpful throughout.
- foldr 17y agoWell, I fly between the US and UK quite frequently, and I don't have any problems. You do seem pretty sensitive (e.g. worrying about the fact that people are "glaring" at you).
- Silhouette 17y ago> Well, I fly between the US and UK quite frequently, and I don't have any problems. Are you a US citizen? (Edit: And on the glaring over the passport thing, that is clearly not a deal-breaker in itself, though for me the arbitrary strip searching is, as is the biometric scanning to enter certain countries.)