8 ms·
I'll agree with your point as soon as Uber signs up to the same level of regulatory restrictions as every phone carrier enjoys. The fact is that there are laws
by onion2k 10y ago
I'll agree with your point as soon as Uber signs up to the same level of regulatory restrictions as every phone carrier enjoys. The fact is that there are laws that strictly prohibit my phone carrier doing certain things with data about my usage. Case in point, the stalking that the article mentions - I don't think employees of my phone carrier can do the same thing. Technically they could because they have the necessary data, but they don't because regulations have been put in place to stop them.
Uber has demonstrated that they can't be trusted with personal data, so I'm quite sure the government will be considering implementing some regulation in their industry too. That's a shame really, because I'm sure most of us would prefer companies weren't restricted by regulation and were just sensible and ethical by default, so laws weren't necessary.
- paublyrne 10y agoThat's a shame really, because I'm sure most of us would prefer companies weren't restricted by regulation and were just sensible and ethical by default, so laws weren't necessary. Interesting. I prefer regulation by default to be honest. Possibly shows my biases from growing up and living in Europe. I see regulation as something you should start with not something you should end up having to do. Just like I prefer civil laws to be in place by default rather than leaving it to people to be good to each other. Maybe I'm in the minority here.
- toyg 10y ago> I see regulation as something you should start with not something you should end up having to do. That's the Platonic/Napoleonic mindset right there :) It's one of the Great Philosophical Questions - do we build society from first principles, or do we just react to what people do as they get together? The latter is the current fashion, at least in theory - in practice, the former keeps coming up over and over, because lawmaking is fundamentally a prescriptive action that instinctively moves from first principles (and it's the only way that lawmakers can forever justify their role: if we ever figured out a society working so well that no reaction or correction is necessary, what would lawmakers do? Write law covering behaviour in places where humans could only potentially exist, i.e. prescribe from first principles). TBH I rarely ever thought about this sort of thing until I moved to the UK, where the average mindset is deeply anti-Napoleonic/anti-Roman.
- mindcrime 10y agoUber has demonstrated that they can't be trusted with personal data And the telecom carriers haven't? Please. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Room_641A https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Room_641A
- ajdlinux 10y agoThe NSA using the power of the state to persuade a telco to intercept some stuff for them is somewhat different from having random employees of a private company just deciding to arbitrarily browse through their corporate databases.
- mindcrime 10y agoTrue. The State has a lot more power on its side, making the former scenario much more of a threat.
- grive 10y agoYou missed the point: the telecom carriers haven't either, however they are regulated, which is not the case for Uber. So the point is moot for telecom carriers because the regulator already swept in. The point is still important to make concerning ongoing practices in unregulated markets, like big data in tech. If you don't like how little is done to correct the NSA using telecom facilities however, you should see with your government, not simply the companies it coerces.
- Avshalom 10y ago>there are laws that strictly prohibit Of course Uber was built on ignoring laws. So there's no reason to believe they'd follow the restrictions even if they were subject to them.
- pjc50 10y ago> are laws that strictly prohibit my phone carrier doing certain things with data about my usage. Unfortunately, that doesn't prohibit foreign intelligence agencies just hacking in and taking it anyway. https://theintercept.com/2014/12/13/belgacom-hack-gchq-inside-story/ https://theintercept.com/2014/12/13/belgacom-hack-gchq-insid... (Pity that I can't see any way of having a cellular network that doesn't know which cell you're in)