3 ms·
> "Inherent" is always with respect to a particular data set I meant it with respect to the hypothetical data set containing all possible data. Either there is
by AnthonyMouse 10y ago
> "Inherent" is always with respect to a particular data set
I meant it with respect to the hypothetical data set containing all possible data. Either there is a quite large disparity in the data which is actually caused by race and so can't be eliminated without considering it, or it's really mostly or entirely caused by some other factors that only correlate with race which we can hypothetically find and use instead.
> Could be. However, due to housing separation, this will also be correlated with race. Regulators consider using factors like this to be "redlining" and strongly frown on it. (Historically this was not true; in fact regulators drew the original red line.)
Traditional redlining was unconditionally denying loans for properties in black neighborhoods. Weighting neighborhoods based on their actual repayment history is something else entirely.
> That certainly might be possible. If you can solve this, and those actually-causative factors do not redundantly encode race (e.g. no redlining), you have built the next unicorn startup. Your customers will be every single bank in America.
Any factor that reduces racial bias is obviously going to correlate at least somewhat with race. It's mathematically necessary. But you can easily tell if a factor does more than redundantly encode race if considering race and that factor predicts more accurately than only considering race.
Determining what the factors actually are would require having the data, which I don't have.