5 ms·
Not an academic, but I feel like charging for-profit journals for rwviews but not community-driven overlay ones is a practical and ethical policy.
by Ericson2314 10y ago
Not an academic, but I feel like charging for-profit journals for rwviews but not community-driven overlay ones is a practical and ethical policy.
- Natsu 10y agoIt would be in isolation, but it would also make it hard for people to replace that income if they came to depend on it.
- Ericson2314 10y agoSure. For the near term that is not an issue. Longer term at least the company is offering more of a service
- Natsu 10y agoIt interferes with a goal of replacing the model entirely. Since it's already clear that academics pay dearly to do this (let alone doing it for free!) it's not clear that the journals add anything but prestige, so anything we can do to eliminate that for a model will allow everyone full access to the literature. If the effort currently wasted here could be redirected into making research available to all, it would be good for everyone except the publishers.
- 08-15 10y agoSo you would become a professional reviewer. Sounds like a reasonable career choice to me.
- impendia 10y agoI certainly agree that it's ethical. As far as practicality goes, demanding payment will invariably amount to refusing the review assignment. I don't have any problem with that, but I don't believe that any publishers will be willing to meet such a demand.
- Ericson2314 10y agoSure. In practice it's just a spin on the boycott.
- tdb7893 10y agoCan you explain to me why academics will spend their time reviewing journals without the expectation of getting paid? I would never accept work where they weren't planning on paying me
- lultimouomo 10y agoAcademics do get paid, and reviews are usually considered part of their work duties. Publishers have simply managed to externalize the cost of reviews (and authorship) to universities, i.e. to students in the case of private university, and to students and states in the case of public ones.
- tdb7893 10y agoComing from working in business it seems kinda weird that they have outsourced not only creating the content but also reviewing the content for free. I wonder why the journals are so expensive when they seem to get a large part of the work for free.
- inimino 10y agoBecause they are entrenched, they publish all the "prestigious" journals, and academics haven't collectively walked away yet.
- 08-15 10y agoI'm sure no commercial publisher will agree. But there is still a difference between "I will not review because I don't feel like it" and "I will not review unless I get paid for it". They send different messages to both the publisher and the scientific community. By the way, feel free to provide your reviewing services for non-profit or open-access journal. Just please, pretty please, don't collaborate with publishers who demand to be paid for a service they don't even provide. And point out that is the publisher who is freeloading, not the researcher who merely refuses to work for free.