5 ms·
I keep wondering why submitting papers to these journals is necessary. Does the research not stand on its own? > I feel in those disciplines researchers are a
by matheusmoreira 10y ago
I keep wondering why submitting papers to these journals is necessary. Does the research not stand on its own?
> I feel in those disciplines researchers are a big happy family
I feel the same way. ArXiv accepts submissions from any registered researcher¹ and it seems so much easier.
¹ https://arxiv.org/help/submit https://arxiv.org/help/submit
- impendia 10y ago> Does the research not stand on its own? Academic mathematician here. It does, sort of, but ..... Say a mathematics postdoc is applying for a job, and she works in underwater basketweaving. The two underwater basketweavers in her dream department read her application and can see that she's brilliant. She's developed a new methodology for weaving rattan under 100 feet of ocean without even getting it wet. She has letters from the most preeminent underwater basketweavers in her field. She should be a shoo-in to get the job. One problem though. A majority of the hiring committee works in different areas of research. One thinks that underwater basketweaving is overhyped. Another thinks that great work was done in the eighties, but all the interesting questions have been solved already. And these people don't put much stock in the letter writers: they have a reputation for writing glowing letters even for mediocre candidates. And, so far, the hiring meeting is deadlocked until the basketweavers pipe in: Our candidate has published in Journal für die reine und angewandte Mathematik and Inventiones Mathematicae and Publications Mathématiques de l'IHÉS. And now, all of a sudden, that postdoc is getting the interview, because her competitors have only published in Mathematische Annalen and Indagationes Mathematicae. (These are all real names of math journals.) That was a bit long winded, and please forgive me if it's a bit silly, but the point is that we need mechanisms to compare researchers working in different subdisciplines, for researchers to "prove" to the community at large that they're doing good work. I wish we could eschew these games, and I certainly wish we could ditch the commercial publishing industry, but we compete with each other for jobs, for grant funding, and for fame, and we need to establish some kind of metric for evaluating researchers which is as fair as possible. It is not perfect; certainly it is not completely fair. But I believe it works reasonably well.
- brians 10y agoDo those sorts of differences in early publishing predict later success—say, in attracting grants or top grad students, when you adjust for the benefits of being at a top school? If not, maybe it doesn't matter which is hired, as with the undergraduates so often told that a whole admitted class could be set aside, the next N taken, and the world would go on.
- impendia 10y ago> Do those sorts of differences in early publishing predict later success? Absolutely yes. They are perhaps the most reliable yardstick for past success that we have available, and past success is the best predictor of future success.
- rflrob 10y agoCitation? Also, it's worth pointing out that the question was not "do they predict success", but "do they predict success controlling for pedigree". Ive been thinking for a while on how you might actually measure the effect of pedigree, beyond the identity of university. I believe that the specific research group matters, but that's a lot harder to prove (smaller N, harder to get reliable data about counterfacuals).
- JumpCrisscross 10y ago> it's worth pointing out that the question was not "do they predict success", but "do they predict success controlling for pedigree" This is a valid social question. As a hirer, however, you are measured by your success, not your success benchmarked to some other thing.
- euyyn 10y ago> we need mechanisms to compare researchers working in different subdisciplines, for researchers to "prove" to the community at large that they're doing good work. But the acceptance into those journals is decided by editors, with the same thought process of the hiring committee. What makes their decision any more valuable?