5 ms·
Name of the Wind is good. Almost too good. The downside of course is that some people fear Rothfuss will never finish the story...
by ythn 10y ago
Name of the Wind is good. Almost too good. The downside of course is that some people fear Rothfuss will never finish the story...
- stinkytaco 10y agoThe farther away I get from Name of the Wind, the worse taste it leaves in my mouth. Perhaps it's because it's unfinished and Kvothe's rosy prose and tendency to superlative is not yet explained. Taken on their own, they just seem overwritten to me.
- r_smart 10y agoThe book weaves a spell around you as your read that makes you love it more than any other book you've read recently. As time passes, and as you read the sequel, the enchantment fades, your senses return and you realize you've been beguiled. Then you hear the first insightful criticism of the work, and it comes tumbling down. That was my experience anyway. I'll also admit to a bit of resentment towards him and GRRM, the combination of which has given me some aversion to reading series that aren't finished yet.
- ythn 10y agoI've been burned twice now. First with Name of the Wind, and again with Blood Song. Both books were incredible masterpieces, and both books were a part of an unfinished series. And at least with Blood Song, the rest of the series was pretty disappointing by comparison. I vowed to never again read an unfinished series (although, I was not burned by Harry Potter, and so far I have not been burned by Stormlight Archive)
- r_smart 10y agoSanderson is probably the only writer I would bank on these days. The man is clearly the most productive writer active in his genre. Mark Lawrence is pretty good too (and I recommend his Broken Empire trilogy!).
- facepalm 10y agoNo bad taste in my mouth from it so far. I think some scenes stand for themselves, for example it has the best dragon scene ever.