8 ms·
In order for discussion to have any meaning, the things we claim have to be 'falsifiable'; there has to be SOME observable consequence of a claim being either t
by cortesoft 10y ago
In order for discussion to have any meaning, the things we claim have to be 'falsifiable'; there has to be SOME observable consequence of a claim being either true or false, even if we aren't able to currently observe it.
So, for religious discussions, what can we possibly discuss? Take any religious claim, and when we ask 'What observation could you make that would demonstrate to you that the claim is false?', the answer is almost always nothing. At that point, what is the use of discussion?
- milesf 10y ago"the answer is almost always nothing" That's just not true. The whole area of Christian Apologetics attempts to answer many of the questions that are raised.
- sago 10y ago> Christian Apologetics attempts to answer many of the questions that are raised With respect, either you misunderstand the point you are responding to, or you misunderstand apologetics, as actually practiced and taught in evangelical institutions. Apologetics, in the evangelical sense (like all terms, it has had varied practical forms), is the rational defence of pre-existing doctrine. It deals with epistemology, natural philosophy, hermeneutics, and other areas only when they can be used to support the doctrine. It is pretty much the opposite of rational inquiry, because it explicitly begins with the conclusion and seeks arguments to justify it. It is, in practice, an example of the parent comment: what falsification of the doctrine would an apologist accept? There would always be another argument, another apologia to bolster the claim. [Source: theological degrees and was an evangelical apologist for 20 years. Books such as Louis Markos, Apologetics for the Twenty-First Century, Crossway, 2010; Peter Kreeft, Handbook of Christian Apologetics, IVP, 1994; and much of the rest of IVP's output.]
- milesf 10y agoOne visit to carm.org or reasonablefaith.org with any questions outside the parameters you've set and you'll see there are ample examples to the contrary.
- sago 10y agoBoth are mainstream evangelical apologetics, of the form I was referring to, and illustrate my point. Please point to pages in either that you feel establish good-faith falsification criteria for any evangelical doctrine, as per the original comment.
- milesf 10y agoGood-faith, meaning what? Non-Christian?
- sago 10y agoGood faith meaning, an honest attempt. It's not an insult to apologetics that they don't. As I said (and as CARM's front page declares) its mission is to defend and justify Christian doctrine, not to investigate whether it is correct. I think you'd be better off rejecting the premise of the original comment (why falsification is important), than you would trying to argue that apologetics operates that way.
- milesf 10y agoWell, I'm 47 now and have had the open challenge since 1990 that if anyone can show me that the Bible is not what it purports to be, then I will have to renounce my faith and search elsewhere. I think that qualifies as an honest attempt :) I'm also not convinced that falsification is the be-all, end-all to deriving meaning. I think it's a very useful tool, but it has its flaws. Looks like we will have to agree to disagree that Christian Apologetics is merely about defending Christian doctrine. It does that, but it does so by encompassing historical, reasoned, and evidential bases. Is it proof? No. Is it a body of evidence that people can examine and decide for themselves if the message is plausible? Most certainly yes.
- sago 10y ago:) Question is, what does it purport to be? This is probably not the venue for this, but it is a rabbit hole, that's for sure. if you're really interested in a respectful disagreement, I'll happily share my email. I have the same open door, if anyone can give me a rational basis that supports their truth claims (without opening the door to claims they reject), then I'll change my view. I have, once. I was an evangelical, I'm not now. > we will have to agree to disagree ... it does so by Why is that disagreeing? I've argued from the outset that it uses tools of rationality in its defence of doctrine. My point has been that it begins with the certainty of the truth of its claims. And you haven't said what else apologetics does other than defend doctrine, just said we disagree on that point. You've not been forthcoming on examples, so far, here's another example. To be clear, it isn't a problem for me that defence (apologia, 1 Pet 3:15) is the point, just that you seem to think I'm missing something, but haven't given an example.
- golemotron 10y ago> So, for religious discussions, what can we possibly discuss? Take any religious claim, and when we ask 'What observation could you make that would demonstrate to you that the claim is false?', the answer is almost always nothing. At that point, what is the use of discussion? That doesn't stop HN from endlessly discussing string theory, simulation-ism, and singularity. None of them are falsifiable.
- cortesoft 10y agoAll of those things are falsifiable, we just don't yet have the capability to conduct the experiments that could possibly falsify them.
- woofyman 10y agoYou're going to use simulated experiments to prove or disprove we're in a simulation? Based on our simulated understanding of the physical laws of our simulated universe?
- cortesoft 10y agoThere are people working on ways we could prove or disprove we are in a simulation. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simulation_hypothesis#Testing_the_hypothesis_physically https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simulation_hypothesis#Testing_...
- roywiggins 10y agoThere are tests that would be evidence for simulation, but not really any that are evidence against. Just because we can't see evidence of the simulation where we look doesn't mean it's not a better simulation than we can probe, or our gods are mucking with our perceptions to make every test come out negative. There aren't any experiments that would actually falsify the hypothesis that our entire world is a fabrication because those experiments could also be fabricated. This is true for finding proof of God: A spectacular miracle is pretty good evidence, but lack of a miracle can't ever disprove the theory.
- pc2g4d 10y ago> In order for discussion to have any meaning, the things we claim have to be 'falsifiable' This assumes a particular brand of empiricism. Which is not falsifiable. Not saying that discounts everything founded on empiricism. Just that the claim you're making doesn't live up to its own standard, and thus isn't necessarily a good way of dismissing other approaches, such as religion.
- danielam 10y ago"In order for discussion to have any meaning, the things we claim have to be 'falsifiable'; there has to be SOME observable consequence of a claim being either true or false, even if we aren't able to currently observe it." Is that claim falsifiable?
- cortesoft 10y agoSure! If you can provide an example of a meaningful conversation where the claims being made are not falsifiable, then it would falsify that statement.