2 ms·
What's most dangerous to me is the idea that without the threat of failure there is no incentive to learn. You are arguing against a straw man. I gave you sev
by btilly 17y ago
What's most dangerous to me is the idea that without the threat of failure there is no incentive to learn.
You are arguing against a straw man. I gave you several specific reasons why it is good to fail students who have not learned the material they need for their further education, and you have addressed none of them.
To your straw man I'll reply with something that should be both obvious and important. There is no possibility of learning when you are put in a classroom with material that assumes you possess a foundation you don't have. Furthermore if the teacher attempts to address the deficiencies of those who haven't learned the basics, there is no possibility of teaching what was supposed to be taught in that class. Therefore social promotion creates a situation where teachers get a choice of bad options, and no available good ones.
The costs of these poorly set up classrooms are extremely difficult to properly measure. But they are absolutely real. And it is important to note that a significant fraction of those costs fall on the students who were not socially promoted.
Looking at the research you quoted, this critical factor is ignored. Yes, students who are allowed to fail learn less than ones who are socially promoted. There wasn't strong evidence whether they learn less by the same grade. But the most important fact to me, whether or not OTHER students learn less when put in classrooms where teachers have a broader mix of students - wasn't even looked at.
Furthermore the option of summer school wasn't addressed. That gives you the best of both worlds. Students who need it get extra time. And get to stay on course. It worked well for me. I personally had a crappy grade 9 French teacher, was passed when I should of failed, then failed grade 10 French. I retook the course in summer school and passed. It would have been better still if I had failed grade 9 French instead. (And better still if I had a decent teacher there, but such is life.)