3 ms·
There is certainly a difference between actual chattel slavery and a glib bit of hyperbolic political sloganeering.
by pvg 10y ago
There is certainly a difference between actual chattel slavery and a glib bit of hyperbolic political sloganeering.
- mindslight 10y agoWhile you downplay my mention as "political sloganeering", it's a core assumption of contemporary political philosophy. A specific designation ("chattel") is only required for distinguishing between different classes of people, when only one class is treated as property. Totalitarianism implicitly asserts all people are its to control, and thus needs no formal designation.
- pvg 10y agoStrike as non-responsive?
- mindslight 10y agoThat seems more applicable to your first response to me. My exact point was that there is a difference (your labeling my phrasing as "political sloganeering" notwithstanding). It only makes sense to compare current society with historic oppression if you also equate us all with that oppressed class (eg the unoppressed class is what has vanished). I'm not saying you can't find further examples of historic government overreach against the citizenry, it's just that slavery is not one of them. edit: Actually scratch that, I see that the comparison was actually being made with torture, which is generally about non-citizens (I hope?). I was addressing the larger topic of societal surveillance, and that to me seems like a definite new phenomenon rather than something comparable to past oppression. Although I'd say it's been created by technological change rather than political change.