4 ms·
I tried to make this switch because I bought into all the online criticism of the new MBP. The build quality was very lacking compared to the new MBP. The scr
by nilkn 10y ago
I tried to make this switch because I bought into all the online criticism of the new MBP.
The build quality was very lacking compared to the new MBP.
The screen wobbled like crazy even when just typing on it.
The model I was using had a really horrible display with active ghosting (not sure if that's the correct term -- it appeared that the refresh rate was just very low, so moving the cursor around or dragging a window would leave a sort of "ghost trail" behind). It's possible this was just a defective display.
The trackpad was nowhere near as good as I was led to believe from online comments. It wasn't horrible, but multitouch gesture recognition felt years behind Apple's. Leaving a finger resting on the trackpad would break all kinds of gestures, but Apple's trackpads handle that just fine. I also didn't realize how nice the Force Touch trackpads are until I went back to a hinge-based trackpad where you can't even click everywhere.
Windows 10 is a big advance over previous versions, and I use it extensively on my desktop at home. However, the experience with a touchpad didn't feel anywhere nearly as polished as on my MacBook. Using trackpad gestures to slide between virtual desktops for instance had a very janky and obviously buggy animation.
Windows now has the Ubuntu subsystem, but I immediately ran into serious dealbreaker issues. I couldn't get Haskell or Elm to run on it because a core system call hadn't been implemented yet. The team is aware of it and I'm sure it's slated to be fixed soon, but I still couldn't do my work on the laptop without firing up a VM or dual booting.
I never used the touch screen and never felt the need to detach the screen and use it as a tablet. The aspect ratio of the screen also bothered me.
I'm now using the much hated 2016 MBP with Touch Bar and am extremely happy with the purchase.
- dmix 10y agoI never used my XPS touchscreen at first but I slowly started to and now I find myself using it at least once a day. Usually when I'm on the couch browsing websites or watching a movie and need to pause it. I'd personally love to try out a laptop that converts. But I guess the use-case in question in this thread is for professional usage where I haven't found utility.
- KirinDave 10y ago> The screen wobbled like crazy even when just typing on it. It sounds to me like you had a somewhat defective model. That said, the surface book is not the best physical laptop computer and will always be less stable than a standard hinge laptop. > Windows now has the Ubuntu subsystem, but I immediately ran into serious dealbreaker issues. I couldn't get Haskell or Elm to run on it because a core system call hadn't been implemented yet. The team is aware of it and I'm sure it's slated to be fixed soon, but I still couldn't do my work on the laptop without firing up a VM or dual booting. Why not just use Powershell and the windows builds? They work fine. Powershell isn't going to kill you. But it's also weird, because I got GHC to compile just fine.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jamesgeck0 10y agoWindows Subsystem for Linux is still very much in beta; I ran into multiple issues just trying to recreate the Ruby development environment I use on my MacBook. It's going to be great in a year or so, but right now there are some pretty sharp edges.