4 ms·
Darwin didn't "discover" evolution. He just happened to collect evidence to support a popular theory. It's been awhile since I read Darwin's book, but he gave
by gwbas1c 10y ago
Darwin didn't "discover" evolution. He just happened to collect evidence to support a popular theory.
It's been awhile since I read Darwin's book, but he gave a lot of credit to his father at the beginning. From what I remember, evolution was more of his father's theory and Charles was young enough to make the trip, and lucky enough to have a father with deep pockets to pay for it.
- motoboi 10y agoThe one with theories was his grandfather. His father did not pay for the trip, which was a scientific expedition payed by the British Crown to survey coasts. Darwin was a minor employee in that ship, hired to collect botanical specimen. In other words, Beagle trip was not for Darwin, but he seized the opportunity and, after almost 20 years of work after that, published his book because someone else was close to publish and he needed to claim the discovery by publishing first.
- mannykannot 10y agoWhile Darwin was formally only a minor employee, if he had any formal position (he was not a naval person), my understanding is that he was primarily there to keep Captain Fitzroy company, in an environment where the combination of social stratification and naval discipline meant that the captain was nominally in a sort of socially-imposed solitary confinement (I wonder how Cook managed on his voyages, but I suspect he was much more flexible than Fitzroy with regards to these matters.) Formally, the ship's surgeon was the expedition's naturalist, as was the practice in those days.
- azakai 10y agoThat's not quite right. Yes, on the one hand his discovery wasn't from nowhere. But it was still a breakthrough - there were multiple theories of evolution in circulation, but most we now know were simply wrong (e.g. Lamarck's theory of evolution). Darwin's theory of evolution through natural selection was not only the sole survivor of those times, but also has stood up til today. It's important we realize that scientific discovery always depends on the work of others ("the shoulders of giants" as the saying goes), but we also have to recognize true breakthroughs as well, and not just say Darwin "collected evidence for a popular theory".
- ChemicalWarfare 10y ago>> but most we now know were simply wrong (e.g. Lamarck's theory of evolution) actually, Lamarck's ideas have made quite a bit of a comeback - epigenetic studies being the prime example. essentially what that's all about is there are DNA-affecting "things" (introduced by things like stress for example) that don't alter the DNA itself but affects how the DNA gets passed on to the offspring. also (even though the scientific community gets all passive aggressive when this subject is brought up) - the truth of the matter is that while adaptation driven by natural selection is definitely "a thing" proven by experiments and observed in nature, the actual speciation driven by natural selection - not so much.
- azakai 10y agoYes, some other ideas have been shown valid too, in some specific cases, including aspects of Lamarck's thinking. But I think it's worth stressing that the primary force that drives evolution is still very clearly natural selection. Not epigenetics, not genetic drift, not randomness, not "spanners" and other structural mechanisms, etc. It's remarkable that Darwin's idea has stood the test of time for so long. He just got it right. Where other influences exist, they tend to be interesting corner cases. Also worth noting that the main exception to natural selection is sexual selection, which was also introduced by Darwin. We shouldn't over-idolize scientific figures, but Darwin was truly remarkable.
- ChemicalWarfare 10y ago>> But I think it's worth stressing that the primary force that drives evolution is still very clearly natural selection. what makes you so sure of that?
- azakai 10y agoWell, it's the universal view in evolutionary biology, in everything I've read and people I've talked to. It's also clearly stated in the opening paragraphs of the wikipedia entry for example [1]. Or were you asking why biologists are so sure? I'm not a biologist, but my understanding is that the evidence for natural selection is simply overwhelming on all levels (archeological, experimental, theoretical, simulations, etc.). Other evolutionary processes have interesting work behind them, but the burden of proof to show they matter as much as natural selection has just not been hit yet. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_selection https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_selection
- thearn4 10y agoI've always thought that Mendel discovered genetics, but from a practical and experimental side. Darwin's work focused on longer timescales. But I don't know how accurate that summary would be.
- Noseshine 10y agoHere is a short excerpt (5 minutes) of an MIT lecture video that tells you a lot about Mendel and where he came from: https://youtu.be/D8m-ZEr9qV8?t=276 https://youtu.be/D8m-ZEr9qV8?t=276 The full course is here - I cannot recommend it enough, the professor is pure gold(!): https://www.edx.org/course/introduction-biology-secret-life-mitx-7-00x-4 https://www.edx.org/course/introduction-biology-secret-life-... Mendel was brilliant - but actually also a bit unlucky (or lucky?). All the traits he checked in his peas were on different chromosomes. He missed the deeper insights resulting form the confusion when inheritance of traits isn't independent, when genes were located on the same chromosome. That lead to the discovery of more mechanisms of inheritance... the random rearrangement of sections of chromosomes that takes place during meiosis.
- azakai 10y agoDarwin discovered the mechanism of natural selection, "survival of the fittest". That requires traits to be heritable, passed from parents to children. Mendel discovered how that works in practice, and in particular, that it was a discrete mechanism - each gene has a finite number of states.
- qntty 10y agoYeah the title bothered me... >The proposal that one type of organism could descend from another type goes back to some of the first pre-Socratic Greek philosophers, such as Anaximander and Empedocles.[34] Such proposals survived into Roman times. The poet and philosopher Lucretius followed Empedocles in his masterwork De rerum natura (On the Nature of Things). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evolution#History_of_evolutionary_thought https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evolution#History_of_evolution... Darwin described one mechanism (i.e. natural selection) that drives evolution.
- sageikosa 10y agoNatural selection and mutation. The most revolutionary thing wasn't that there was change, but that the changes were effectively "random" change. Randomness and species interrelatedness is what drove (still drives) teleological fanatics absolutely nuts.
- azakai 10y agoTo be fair to Darwin, he proposed another mechanism as well, sexual selection. Also, his two mechanisms were revolutionary at the time, and many decades later remain the most important factors in our understanding of evolution. Yes, the general idea of evolution as "species change, rise and fall" is not a new one in Darwin's time. But today when we say "evolution" we basically mean "evolution by natural selection" which is Darwin's novelty.