3 ms·
I think it's unfortunate when people ignore the possibility of psychosomatic symptoms, but even more dangerous when they attribute every issue to it. It should
by nickcoury 10y ago
I think it's unfortunate when people ignore the possibility of psychosomatic symptoms, but even more dangerous when they attribute every issue to it. It should be a tool in the toolbox, a possible explanation/approach to ailments that are sometimes simple and singular but often times complex and multi-faceted.
My N=1:
I have chronic back issues. At best it's general tightness and fatigue, but can also be sore and painful. In particular I had two incidents in 2011 (in a matter of seconds) and 2012 (over a couple days) where my back spasmed and left me crippled, unable to move without knife-stabbing pains and unable walk down hallways without holding onto a wall. Both lasted almost a month, and were followed by months of heightened soreness.
I was 23/24 at the time, with no preexisting health issues. I'm a regular runner and in great health otherwise. I tried to fix this with deep tissue massage and core/strengthening regimens, and largely those helped keep the pain levels down but really only halved the symptoms at best. A friend had been recommending Sarno's 'A Divided Mind' which is all about the psychosomatic diagnosis since the first incident, but I had dismissed it. Finally in 2013, as I felt a new round of the spasms coming, I gave it a shot. Lo and behold, it became the single most effective tool I've found to manage my back issues. I identified that each spasm came with a major emotionally loaded event. In 2011 it was unrealistic pressure to compete at a big running race I had been training for. In 2012 it was participating in the search and rescue for a dear friend who was lost (and died) in the wilderness. In 2013 it was a nasty falling out with my best friend (and brother) at the time.
I don't believe the mechanisms are fully understood, and I think Sarno in particular does too much hand waving. But using his approach was the first time in years that I had no discernible back issues. I liken it to getting butterflies in your stomach. Your mind and emotions can trigger physiological changes to blood vessels, nerves, muscles, etc. that in turn can cause real issues. I also don't believe it's the only factor. I started an office job in 2015, and back issues have come back that I attribute 100% to the office lifestyle. I've found no relief with the psychosomatic approach, but do better with a sit/stand desk, breaks, and daily exercise.
Overall, I think a ton of people could benefit from approaching health issues from a psychosomatic perspective as one of many possible diagnoses. I also agree there are so many other possibilities that assuming it is always in your head is ignorant, neglectful, and downright dangerous.
- eth0up 10y agoYou seem to have a practical outlook on the subject and I probably concur. I also think of, for example, the ascetic who self-immolates and does not succumb to the pain, but chars under the fire despite. Or the one who fasts for long durations enduring hunger and psychological torment but also atrophy and malnutrition. Or the putatively successful surgery substituting hypnosis for anesthesia. Certainly stress can weather a body or mind, and a salubrious head can fortify them. Perhaps there's an oxymoron or semantic trickster behind "drug. induced. psychosis.", and it could be referred to as "toxic state" instead. Regardless, not every individual is prepared for taking a Mind Over Matter approach to health, especially in terminal conditions. I think it might be a wiser approach to tout the possible benefits of applied psychology rather than indict the mind as the culprit of most illness. Also, thanks for the replies/comments. Edit: "/comments"
- FreeFull 10y agoI have had problems in back pain, and it's always been triggered by the back being in a bad position for an extended amount of time. Once the pain starts, it makes the muscles tense up, which only makes the pain worse.. It can be hard to get out of that loop. I bet your back pain had some physical origin too, but your state of mind helped keep your muscles relaxed, and let your back recover quickly rather than slowly.
- icantdrive55 10y agoI agree with most back pain, but not with testiculiar pain. I think the "insomnia" claim threw the doctor off? I went to Chiropractic school, until I realized there's no such thing as a Subluxation, except in a handful of people--usually due to trama that only surgery can fix. While, I don't believe in subluxation, I do belive, for some reason the arterioles around the back constrict, and this is what causes pain. When the stress goes away, or the body just returns to homeostasis; the pain goes away. That's might be why massage, chiropractic, and just moving around will cause the pain to go away? I belive their doing research on this hypothesis. I remember twenty years ago, Dr. Dean Edell talking about back pain. Something he was very familiar with himself. He said they have done studies where the looked at cadavers, and found many people have bulging discs, bone spurs, etc. in patients who never complained of back pain. Chronic debilitation pain=might be something serious. The back that "goes out" for a few day=probally nothing to worry about?