4 ms·
> With Trump elected, Europe is turning to itself for its defence Are you really trying to say that Trump, and not Putin, is the primary reason for this? Also
by golergka 10y ago
> With Trump elected, Europe is turning to itself for its defence
Are you really trying to say that Trump, and not Putin, is the primary reason for this?
Also, I thought that political threads were banned on HN now; aren't they?
- usrusr 10y ago> Are you really trying to say that Trump, and not Putin, is the primary reason for this? Sure. The NATO of old was facing off against much stronger opposition than Putin today, without even the slightest trace of doubt in commitment coming up. Trump is certainly not the only factor that erodes trust in NATO deterrence (Brexit, Erdogan and NATO overexpansion are other important contributors to the general uneasiness), but he is the most visible one. Visible cracks are bad because there will always be people (on all sides!) who see personal incentive to widen them and if they succeed, the mere thought that limited scope wars could be possible will endanger peace.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> Are you really trying to say that Trump, and not Putin, is the primary reason for this? If Trump is part of the mechanism, Putin is still the reason.
- enraged_camel 10y ago>>Also, I thought that political threads were banned on HN now; aren't they? No, the "ban" was temporary, and lifted only a few days after it was put in place.
- Florin_Andrei 10y ago> Are you really trying to say that Trump, and not Putin, is the primary reason for this? Not sure why you're being downvoted, it's a good question. The way I see it, it's an overall pandemic of malaise, a regression to a more primal state, affecting the "West" primarily, but certainly influencing the whole world to some extent. Brexit is a symptom. The Trump madness is a symptom. Le Pen is a symptom. Putin has been a symptom and an instrument and an agent for a long time. ISIS is an example outside of the West of the same thing. Fear and lies. Facts don't matter anymore, truth is being trampled into the ground, and the world's state of mind is gradually turning dark. Where violence has an opportunity, it breaks out. Fortunately, not much of this has been translated into material consequences (except for ISIS and so on), but at the psychological level it's really bad. If it stays mostly on that level, then perhaps there is a way out eventually.
- ipnon 10y agoHow do you alleviate this primal state in people? Give them everything they need to live comfortably and decently? Isn't this the result of the whole post-Cold War project called Capitalism (capital C)? What do people need in order to have them desire peace and cooperation with all of humanity without qualifications? There are so many questions that still need to be answered.
- pmoriarty 10y ago"Also, I thought that political threads were banned on HN now; aren't they?" The ban has been lifted. See: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13131251 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13131251