6 ms·
> unless the user yanks the battery out of the back. That is presumably a rare occurrence for your typical user. I've witnessed a number of phones with the "cr
by derefr 10y ago
> unless the user yanks the battery out of the back. That is presumably a rare occurrence for your typical user.
I've witnessed a number of phones with the "crumple zone"-alike feature of effectively ejecting the battery cover + battery out of the phone whenever you drop it.
- ygra 10y agoI would hope dropping a phone is also a rare occurrence for typical phone users. Otherwise they're probably better off getting a Nokia 3210 instead of a smartphone with glass screen.
- iopq 10y ago> I would hope dropping a phone is also a rare occurrence for typical phone users. I drop my phone all the time and I don't have a case. It's fine.
- awjr 10y agoI dropped my phone at the weekend without a case. I now have a shattered screen. :/ It's about the 5th time I've dropped my phone and this is the first time something like this has happened.
- josephg 10y agoApparently the glass in phone screens develops micro fractures from being dropped. (Well, from hitting the ground). You can't see them with the naked eye, but they weaken the glass and they grow with each successive drop. It's probably not just bad luck that the glass happened to break after the Nth time you dropped it. It was bound to happen if you kept dropping the device.
- marvy 10y agoMe too, though the screen did get a small crack once. If there was a 1% chance of file system corruption each time I dropped my phone, it would have happened to me by now, I think. And usually when I drop my phone, the battery comes out. It used to happen only half the time, but I think the cover got loosened as a result of all the times I dropped it, so now the battery falls out pretty much every time.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- nabanicu 10y agoIt's 2016, if you abruptly shut down a computer in the middle of a filesystem write the chances of ending up with a corrupted filesystem are of around a 0 %, so those are the chances of getting a brick when you drop your mobile.
- jbg_ 10y agoIf you mount with nobarrier I'd say that the chances are somewhat higher than 0%
- dilap 10y agoyou could have corruption and not know. i'm pretty sure on the mac hfs+ corrupts files all the time (why? i've run into it multiple times). but it's not necessarily something you'll immediately notice.
- marvy 10y agoThat's upsetting. I'll try not to drop my phone while an update is in progress in that case.
- skeptic2718 10y agoCarpet or hard floor (ceramic, etc) ?
- iopq 10y agoWood floor and sometimes concrete. I don't drop it from my hand, usually from a pocket or lap, though.
- cuu508 10y agoWhat phone do you have?
- paublyrne 10y agoI drop my phone with unnerving regularity, but I use a case and it's always fine. I suspect that if I didn't have a case I wouldn't drop it so often.
- mlvljr 10y agohappens easily with my Lumia :)
- vacri 10y agoI have to go with the article's position, though - I'd rather have the few seconds data loss and get the better responsiveness and a longer-lived device.
- sdenton4 10y agoIt all depends which few seconds of data are lost, though, right? Do you just lose a new contact, or corrupt an essential database?
- kogepathic 10y ago> Do you just lose a new contact Are people creating new contacts that often on a phone? I probably do that only a few times per week. If the phone crashed immediately following the input, I'd just ask the person for their details again. > corrupt an essential database? It would only corrupt application data. Android isn't completely stupid, /system is mounted read-only on every Android phone I've ever seen. I guess it depends on how highly you depend on application data remaining consistent. Presumably the corruption would only apply to data that was modified but had not been flushed to flash before the power cycle, so at rest data shouldn't be affected.
- jcheng 10y ago> at rest data shouldn't be modified If your data is kept in a SQLite database or any other type of compound storage scheme it's entirely possible to lose data that wasn't being modified, due to corruption of the metadata that governs the layout of the file (actually I don't have experience with SQLite file format specifically, but I ruined my startup's launch a decade ago with almost identical reasoning--thousands of pressed CD-ROMs in the garbage).
- Sean1708 10y ago> I probably do that only a few times per week. Look at Mr. Popular over here.
- piaste 10y ago
- nix0n 10y agoI've seen this too, but the Moto Z is not one of these phones (the battery is not "user"-removable).