10 ms·
SF blasts Uber, Lyft for downtown traffic congestion
- JumpCrisscross 10y agoDo we have supporting data? Or is the taxi lobby just smarting up? In New York, the taxis made the same case--that Uber et al increased traffic. This claim was found wanting [1]. In God we trust; all else bring data. [1] http://www.nytimes.com/2016/01/16/nyregion/uber-not-to-blame-for-rise-in-manhattan-traffic-congestion-report-says.html http://www.nytimes.com/2016/01/16/nyregion/uber-not-to-blame...
- bigethan 10y agoAs a downtown sf commute cyclist, my anecdotal experience is that traffic now is much worse than the same time last year. And almost all the bad actors in traffic who are causing slowdowns and jams have uber and lyft stickers in their windows. I don't believe in God, but I do believe that if I get hit on my bike uber/lyft will be responsible.
- friedman23 10y agoThe population of SF has been growing, it makes sense that traffic is worse. Until there is evidence of a causal link between ride sharing and traffic I'd be hesitant to believe any of it.
- bigethan 10y agoSo your initial assumption (population growth increases traffic) without evidence is true, but my experience is unbelievable? Seems like a weird way to reply if you want to have a meaningful conversation.
- friedman23 10y agohttps://www.google.com/search?q=population+density+and+traffic&rlz=1C5CHFA_enUS722&oq=population+density+and+traffic&aqs=chrome..69i57.9218j0j7&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8 https://www.google.com/search?q=population+density+and+traff... 2 seconds to search for this.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- rodrickbrown 10y agoThis makes no sense what do they think would happen if Uber and Lyft went away????
- slaveofallah93 10y agoPerhaps they think people would switch to public transit like buses or Caltrain.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- pizzacowboy 10y agoPrecisely. Although, they're a little naïve if they think that's a realistic alternative. The transit system is horrific, having used it for 3.5 years. We're largely in this mess because the transit system is such a mess. I'm surprised the article didn't also mention the congestion issues at SFO. The departures deck is a mess now that all Lyft/Uber riders are directed there for pick-up.
- abalone 10y agoWhat precisely is SF's theory here re: congestion? Previously taxis would circle streets much less efficiently than a smartphone-hailed pickup. Also they wouldn't pool rides anywhere nearly as effectively. So if they're seeing more traffic on the road, what's the cause? Has there been population growth of riders? That wouldn't be Uber/Lyft's fault. In fact they may have handled the growth more efficiently than just putting more traditional taxis on the road. Are riders shifting from public transit to rideshares? That would be Uber/Lyft's fault. But also public transit's. Is it that more availability has lowered the wait times vs taxis? That would definitely be Uber/Lyft's fault. But it also makes riding a much nicer experience, saves riders a lot of time, etc.
- jacquesgt 10y agoTheir theory is spelled out pretty clearly in the article. There are 1800 taxicabs permitted to operate in the city and many more Ubers/Lyfts. The fact that people who use Uber and Lyft have to wait less is nice for them, but not so nice if the extra cars for hire circling for fares results in slower commutes for public transit users.
- abalone 10y agoDoes it result in significantly slower muni? Many major downtown routes have dedicated bus lanes, and obviously there is no impact on the subway.
- bigethan 10y agoHave you actually been in sf traffic in the uber/lyft world? My observations from my life: -Double parking everywhere waiting for pickup / dropoff /routing. Blocking car and bike lanes. -riders getting out into traffic -erratic drivers (new to SF, easily lost) Its pretty terrible. If they painted their cars yellow, and made them pickup and drop off at corners / out if the flow of traffic things would be way better (imho).
- iopq 10y agoYou have to do this, otherwise the passenger will never find you. Passengers DO NOT walk to you when you pick them up. Even if you're waiting around the corner like 30 steps away.
- iambateman 10y agoI was just in SF for the first time and couldn't believe that the public transit was painfully loud. We switched to Uber because of how uncomfortable the transit ride was. For all the hand-wringing over too many cars, they might consider quieting the metro.
- jacobolus 10y agoWhere are you comparing it to? In my experience the quietest subways are from the past 20 years or so. BART first started running in ~1970.
- hkmurakami 10y agoWellBart is about the same noise level as th Boston green line which is the oldest subway in the country.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- codemac 10y agoWell bart is famous for having super loud screeching wheels[0], but they will be replaced by around 2021.. The screeching is absolutely loud for a subway, though I think the noise all together isn't so bad relative to other subways. [0]: https://ww2.kqed.org/news/2016/08/02/why-are-bart-trains-so-loud/ https://ww2.kqed.org/news/2016/08/02/why-are-bart-trains-so-... [1]: https://www.bart.gov/news/articles/2016/news20160831 https://www.bart.gov/news/articles/2016/news20160831
- shinymark 10y agoYes, it is awful. I've spent significant time in Japan and can't believe how quiet the trains are - including the high-speed bullet trains - compared to the awful screeching of the train I grew up riding: BART.
- ikonst 10y ago
- mathattack 10y agoThis seems very silly. You're trying to minimize the amount of cars on the road. The amount of people-miles of passengers is roughly constant. The only thing that reduces car-miles is ride sharing. Uber (and Lyft and possibly Waze) is much more efficient at this than Taxis. And Uber drivers have every incentive to not be idle. The issue isn't too many cars. It's too many solo drivers or single passengers.
- jdavis703 10y agoWhy is Uber more efficient than taxis? Friendlier, faster to dispatch, no discrimination, no tipping, sure Uber/Lyft wins those hands down. But at the end of the day what stops a cab from having the same load as a TNC vehicle?
- khuey 10y agoThere's no cab equivalent to Uber Pool/Lyft Line.
- iopq 10y agoBecause I usually drive 2 passengers at the same time. I start by picking someone up. Then Uber app finds someone half way to the first person's destination. After I drop off the first person it finds someone else to pick up on the way, etc. So I end up with an average of 2 people in my car. Sometimes I pick up a group of two people while I already have a passenger. That's four people in the same car, I'm not sure if it goes up to five. I've never seen taxis do this.
- acchow 10y agoCab doesn't pick up more passengers during a ride (a la Uber Pool/Lyft line). Also, dropping off a passenger in a uber/lyft is much less disruptive to traffic flow than a traditional cab which has to process a payment.
- joshjje 10y agoNow, if we could only institute/implement a tuck and roll deployment system. Tuck and roll, grandma!
- khuey 10y agoSan Francisco really needs to get rid of a bunch of curbside car storage to make room for loading zones.
- cerrelio 10y agoSF needs to worry about its own transit issues. MUNI stops at rush hour are poorly serviced. I can't get on most of the trains that pass through Civic Center, so I usually end up going inbound to Montgomery or Embarcadero so I can actually board.
- abritinthebay 10y agoThat's great SF - get some functioning, not-shitty, well funded public transport and people won't feel the need to use Uber.. ... what's that? Not a chance in hell? Well then. (But seriously - BART is chronically underfunded, Muni trains are unreliably scheduled, Muni busses are the most dangerous and shady public busses I've used in the western world... and very little of it actually serves anywhere other than the busses which have to fight the same traffic...)
- Tempest1981 10y agoExtending BART is very expensive ($billions), esp. in a city that is already "built out", like SF is. On the other hand, we managed to fund High Speed Rail at over $60 billion.
- azinman2 10y agoPublic transport is a joke, the city is unable to adequately engineer traffic well or plan for it, and when something comes in to meet actual demand -- that's the problem? Travel around other cities and it's apparently which city cares about advancing its transport: Berlin, Paris, Shanghai, Tokyo, Kyoto, Barcelona, Nyc, even Boston, DC and Beijing are better. If subways aren't possible, use light rail or BRT. But don't blend them with equal priority on the traffic lights -- it defeats the point. I hate MUNI so much!!!
- idlewords 10y agoThe subway in DC is a diaster, with antiquated cabling causing a constant risk of fires. The agency is prevented from running all-eight-car trains because the power system wouldn't be able to handle it. http://www.ntsb.gov/news/press-releases/Pages/PR20150608.aspx http://www.ntsb.gov/news/press-releases/Pages/PR20150608.asp...
- azinman2 10y agoThat was the "or even" part ;) Honestly I'd rather have the option than no option at all. It got me around D.C. last time I was there...
- kevinkimball 10y agoSFMTA should remove parking and replace it with passenger loading zones. That way, they wouldn't be blocking traffic, including public transportation. It's well known that free and subsidized parking encourages driving. Currently, passenger loading zones must be requested and paid for by businesses that want it, to the tune of thousands of dollars a year. [1] They don't, so rideshare and taxi drivers just block traffic lanes. There is no mechanism for passenger loading zones to be requested by citizens or designated by the city for public benefit. [1] https://www.sfmta.com/getting-around/parking/curb-colors https://www.sfmta.com/getting-around/parking/curb-colors
- dangero 10y agoI was recently in SF and I was surprised to find that Uber Pool cost was very similar to Bart cost going to and from SFO. Uber is certainly preferable to having everyone drive their own car. Talk about congestion. Why doesn't SF do what Paris just did: Make public transit free. If they did that I would definitely use Bart more.
- idlewords 10y agoI don't think BART could handle the extra load. http://www.sfgate.com/bayarea/article/BART-can-t-keep-pace-with-rising-crush-loads-6192950.php http://www.sfgate.com/bayarea/article/BART-can-t-keep-pace-w...
- jmspring 10y agoI've not cycled in SF for commute reasons since the pre uber days. That said, other cyclists -- bike messengers -- were the largest danger to other cyclist, second was other cyclists, third was Muni. From a damage perspective, Muni would be number one in the injury case. Drivers, cyclists, and Muni, to this day, are selfish assholes. Blaming it purely on Uber, no. SF transit policies have lead to this. Drive mission, you used to go straight most of the route... now only muni, taxis and assholes ignoring the law. The problems aren't just due to muni/Lyft
- bigethan 10y agoTry cycling in SF again. Things have changed a lot in the last year or so. I've been bike commuting in SF for 10 years, and the last year has been by far the worst. And most bad actors are uber and lyft cars.
- aclimatt 10y agoWe should at least start by taking this with a grain of salt, because according to the article: > Notably, no study has been completed to study Uber or Lyft’s effects on San Francisco traffic However, similar to what others have said, anecdotally I definitely agree. In the last four years, particularly Gough and Franklin have gone from a viable alternative to Van Ness to completely unusable -- particularly because Google Maps and Waze (what 99% of drivers use) route them down there instead of other streets. I have a habit of asking where drivers are from, and the vast majority of them are from out of town and commute to SF to drive for Uber / Lyft. Again, it's still anecdotal, but ask drivers next time you get in a ride and I think it'll become pretty clear where all the traffic is coming from. But you know what? I blame the SFMTA. This isn't User's fault, this is SF's fault for not building a functional transit system (and the voters for not funding it) 30 years ago. Uber began because Travis couldn't catch a cab. If Travis lived in Madrid, he would have taken the subway, he would have got there on time, and Uber never would have existed. SF's transit mismanagement created an environment that could only be solved by something like Uber (or Scoot, which I now almost use exclusively). If San Francisco wants to fix its traffic problems, it needs to stop prioritizing private cars driving faster, and needs to focus on more subways, more bus only lanes, more cycling lanes, and more pedestrian-only streets. Private automobiles are not the way most of the developed world (outside of America) gets around, and if Tokyo, a city of 31 million people can get around efficiency without traffic, so can paltry San Francisco. We should be building 10 subway lines at a time, and if that means tripling our taxes to pay for it, count me in. But so far all the willpower I've seen is to run busses faster down Van Ness and one new subway that goes a bit over a mile. I'm pretty sure the folks in the Richmond have been saying this ever since BART pulled out in the 70s. Maybe self-driving cars will fix it all, but I'm still skeptical. So far I haven't seen a permanent solution to traffic past a proper heavy-rail, grade-separated train.
- closeparen 10y ago>and more pedestrian-only streets. Where in SF is this an actual problem? The only inadequate sidewalks I've ever encountered were due to construction encroachments, not actual design.
- 10y ago
- clhodapp 10y agoI'm pretty sure that a lot more people are using ride sharing services in the SF Bay Area because all of the public transit systems are overcrowded during peak hours and most have additional major issues. BART is too expensive. Muni is prone to unexpectedly large time gaps between buses/trains and doesn't have sufficient subway coverage. Caltrain runs too infrequently. The ferries also seem to run pretty infrequently (though I have less experience with them than the other modes of transit). I don't have any direct evidence for this but it feels pretty obvious: when your public transit systems are already running at full capacity during peak hours and you have people moving into your area, the roads are going to end up completely congested. It certainly isn't the fault of whatever entity is putting cars on the road that the roads are full. After all, people are going to try to live their lives and there really isn't another reasonable way to make more-than-a-few-blocks trips during these hours. I only see a few ways to improve things: a) Increase public transit capacity and then make it more desirable to take public transit (and continually repeat because now your public transit is overcrowded again) and b) Spread out the "peak hours" time over more of the day. Unfortunately, improving public transit can take years or even decades. So we won't get much mileage out of this for a while, but we should still be investing a lot more heavily than we are because this is the only "scalable" fix. It can only be done a limited number of times, but I think we could do a lot better at improving the situation on a shorter timescale with the other option: spreading "peak hours" over more of the day. This can be accomplished by incentivizing companies to shift their workdays so that they start before or after 9 (with a corresponding change at the end of the day). PS: I haven't lived in the peninsula for a couple years at this point, but when I left, Caltrain had just started running a "ridership campaign" while all of its commute-hour trains were standing-room-only. This is ridiculous. The problem is not that not enough people want to take public transit, the problem is that there's not enough capacity!
- larryjounce 10y agoI'd love to see some real data from San Francisco as well, but I'm almost certain San Francisco is well above capacity. The following article points out some interesting facts about vehicles in motion in relation to gridlock. Unregulated ride sharing is definitely having an impact, how much is the question. http://thepenngazette.com/uber-gridlock/ http://thepenngazette.com/uber-gridlock/