2 ms·
The people who are demoing this are so enamoured with their technology that they have lost touch with reality. They casually mention the model does not feel pa
by tinus_hn 10y ago
The people who are demoing this are so enamoured with their technology that they have lost touch with reality.
They casually mention the model does not feel pain and so uses its head as a leg. It's so smart! But they don't realize the end result is an insult to those who are struggling because of disability. All they see is cool technology.
I think the demo shows great promise, either for a grotesque human form in a zombie scenario or some animal or mechanical creature. Considering the type of stories mr. Miyazaki is know for the horror scenario was a poor choice. If the technology isn't ready for something better they shouldn't have presented it to him.
- candiodari 10y agoFirstly this is a genetic algorithm designed walk. If that is your criticism, it's easy to fix. Simply make the head feel pain, as an extra constraint. This algorithm is trying to find ways of moving the body it was given in a way that would work (like a human or any animal would. This algorithm is trying to be smart about moving around, it's NOT trying to imitate human animators. You want that, we have algorithms for that as well. Second, is this really a valid criticism ? In a pinch, I have in fact used my head as an appendage to move around, to support things when moving furniture, and a million other ways so ... I don't see the problem. I have in fact moved furniture with a partially disabled person that used his head as an appendage to keep furniture stable just like I did. I always found that disabled people prefer that you just ignore their disabilities, as much as possible (unless it makes something truly impossible for them, but hard is just fine). Is that a wrong attitude ?