4 ms·
>> both sides of the story That there is part of the problem. That is a very western phrase that reflects an ingrained system at the root of the problem. Bin
by sandworm101 10y ago
>> both sides of the story
That there is part of the problem. That is a very western phrase that reflects an ingrained system at the root of the problem. Binary is for silicon. There are multiple sides, or there is one. There is almost never exactly two. But we are trained to expect equal time for "both sides". It makes people think they are well-informed, when in reality if you are hearing exactly two stories you are almost certainly being hoodwinked.
This isn't Hotelling. Hotelling occurs where the proponents choose their sides, their stances in a debate. When a news organization wants to inform people that a meteor is heading to earth, picking a pro and con pundit isn't hotelling. That's just manufacturing a controversy where none exists. Note that weather forecasts rarely give "both sides" ... until one wants estimates beyond next month. Then they have to bring in the pro/con people in that manufactured controversy.
A careful citizen should dismiss two-sided debates, or at least realize that "both sides" is a marketing trick. Read the research. Read, and understand, the statistics.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hotelling%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hotelling%27s_law
- hrxn 10y agoBoth sides is not a marketing trick. And comparing this with weather forecasts is a false equivalence.
- tunap 10y agoI believe what parent is claiming is 'both sides' is a black & white gimmick that does not depict the spectrum between two polarized extremes.
- SomeStupidPoint 10y agoI think even more that most issues are multi-dimensional, and you can't even explain it as a spectrum between two extremes -- you can reasonably be in one of a half-dozen different takes on the issue, depending on how you feel about particular aspects or sub-issues.
- hrxn 10y ago"Both sides" is just a shorthand expression for principles otherwise better understandable as "due process", but this is hard to summarize in just some words or a couple sentences. It basically means there are two sides (at least) to everything, that can't just be disregarded. Exceptions prove the rule, of course. On another point, Hotelling's law is a really poor example when it comes to debates or questions of politics, in my opinion.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoRelated - the truth doesn't have any obligation to fall exactly in the middle between two extremes, or in a geometrical center between many points of view. It can really be, that one side is mostly wrong, and the other mostly right.