6 ms·
> ‘Non-invasive advertising’ is an oxymoron. Truly non-invasive advertising would be no advertising at all. You can't be taken seriously if your argument is to
by andrewflnr 10y ago
> ‘Non-invasive advertising’ is an oxymoron. Truly non-invasive advertising would be no advertising at all.
You can't be taken seriously if your argument is to loudly change all the definitions to fit your worldview. Show me a better world that actually works.
- Fnoord 10y ago> Show me a better world that actually works. Try teleporting back to the 20th century and experience the internet in its full glory. Without advertising.
- sanswork 10y agoIf you think there was no advertising on the internet in the 20th century then you probably weren't on the internet in the 20th century. If anything it was more obnoxious back then with poorly animated flashing banners on every page.
- TheOtherHobbes 10y agoNot for the first couple of years of public early-adopter access during the mid-90s. The first couple of years were a glorious outburst of creative kookiness and cultural insanity. Then the spammers, scammers, and MBAs moved in. And here we are.
- sanswork 10y agoSpam goes back to the 70s. On the web side I remember back to at least 95 pretty well and there were banner ads everywhere. I had a homepage with like 3-4 web ring banners on it + the ads from Geocities themselves. A quick look says the first banner ads appeared in 1994 and the first paid ads in 1993. I think you're probably looking back with rose tinted glasses.
- Fnoord 10y agoIts not obnoxious now because uBlock and spam filters works so well, and HTML5 killed Flash. If you don't take such quality filters into account, advertising is far, far worse nowadays. We're talking about everything before the dotcom boom here. The internet was a lot bigger than WWW, and Macromedia Flash (and Doubleclick) were initiated in 1996. That covers less than 5% of the 20th century. Also, Flash wasn't (ab)used right away for advertising, and if one didn't have it installed not much was missed. Perhaps an online Flash game or two didn't work. No big deal. There was spam on Usenet (the first spam coming from Digital Equipment Corp or was it SUN in the early 80s) and IRC, but it wasn't acceptable.
- sanswork 10y agoWe're talking about 5% of the 20th century because for most people the internet was only available for around 5% of the 20th century. Doubleclick wasn't the first ad network. There was acceptable advertising on usenet too in the form of signatures.
- bigbugbag 10y agoWell yes, there was a period of time during the 20th century when all commercial activities were banned from the internet, until around 1995 IIANM. Basically Internet was non commercial from about 1978 to 1995, though I think the first banner ad came to existence 1 year before in 1994, that's still a longer period without ads than with.
- sanswork 10y agoIf you look at archives of USENET from those time periods plenty of people had ads in their signatures for example and even if you don't count that the first spam message was sent in 1978 so that whole time period is post internet ads.
- imagist 10y agoBut that's not what he's doing. The entire purpose of advertising is to put ideas in your head--that's invasive. That's not changing the definitions of words, that's what those words mean in common parlance.
- eropple 10y agoThat's also the purpose of an editorial.
- praisewhitey 10y agoThe purpose of all communication really.
- imagist 10y agoBut I seek out communication with people whose ideas I care about. That's very different from having someone shove their self-serving ideas in front of me.
- GavinMcG 10y agoBut you have a choice about whether to read that.
- jpindar 10y agoDunno about you, but I like having ideas in my head.
- baddox 10y agoWhat definitions are being changed? It's pretty reasonable to claim that if you don't want to see any ads (which is clearly the position in the article), then any ads you do see are invasive.
- BookmarkSaver 10y agoBecause you don't get to just chose the content on a page you load that you want to see. A news article with ads is paid for by those ads, and if you want to go to their website to read it you are implicitly agreeing to see those ads. If you don't want to be "invaded" by ads, then don't go to pages with ads.
- baddox 10y ago> Because you don't get to just chose the content on a page you load that you want to see. What do you mean? Of course you get to do that. That's exactly what ad blockers do. > A news article with ads is paid for by those ads, and if you want to go to their website to read it you are implicitly agreeing to see those ads. You have no case to say I'm "implicitly agreeing" to see ads when in fact I am explicitly running software to prevent me from seeing them. This "implicit agreement" argument is the worst anti-adblocking argument. It would be like me ordering a pizza, picking off the olives, and being told that I have to eat those since I implicitly agreed to olives when I ordered the pizza. Nope, the act of picking off the olives is as explicit as I could possibly get that I don't want the olives.
- BookmarkSaver 10y ago>That's exactly what ad blockers do. That's the same thing as saying that buying a lockpicking kit is the same as being given permission to enter private property. You are using an outside exploit to get around the terms that the provider laid out in order to see their content. You are confusing the ability to filter the content with the right to filter that content. > It would be like me ordering a pizza, picking off the olives, and being told that I have to eat those since I implicitly agreed to olives when I ordered the pizza. Nope, the act of picking off the olives is as explicit as I could possibly get that I don't want the olives. This is a completely ridiculous and useless analogy. You bought that pizza, and you own it. Period. When you go to a website, you are not buying or owning anything. You are requesting a set of data and refusing the price that comes along with it. >You have no case to say I'm "implicitly agreeing" to see ads when in fact I am explicitly running software to prevent me from seeing them. This completely disregards the fact that the website has little or no power to stop you from doing so. You are implicitly agreeing to it, and then you are failing to hold up your end of the deal. If you cannot see that, then you are just being self-entitled close-minded to the obvious truths that inconvenience you.
- bunderbunder 10y agoI don't take this as an attempt to re-define anything. It's a pretty clear statement of a (admittedly strong opinion): Advertising is, by its very nature, an intrusion. I don't think that is completely out of line. An ad's purpose is to convince me to part with some amount of my time or money. And even when they don't managed to do that, they still have an impact on my environment. It ends up cluttered with animated banner ads and auto-playing videos and tasteless billboards and sudden jumps in the audio volume coming out of my radio. It fills my mental space with memes that are deliberately engineered to harm my mental health by convincing me that I'm too hairy and smelly and old and bald and bored and overweight and under-penised and any number of other things that I wouldn't be the slightest bit worried about otherwise. Which isn't to say that there aren't ads that I appreciate (shout out to Metromile for running the most recent subway ad to get me to buy a product), but they do seem to be a relative rarity in the grand scheme of things. That's coming from someone who deliberately tries to occupy a low-ad environment by avoiding things like live TV, though, so there's my bias.
- bigbugbag 10y agoWell, isn't advertising invasive by essence? The point of advertising being to enter and occupy a part of your mind in order to persuade you.