3 ms·
Can't agree more. Quake 2 sure did have cover mechanics, RPG elements, crafting, AI squadmates, QTEs, realistic lighting, vehicles, mounted weapons, set pieces,
by throwanem 10y ago
Can't agree more. Quake 2 sure did have cover mechanics, RPG elements, crafting, AI squadmates, QTEs, realistic lighting, vehicles, mounted weapons, set pieces, anything to do other than killing things and fetching things, interesting characters, characters, a branching story, a well-told story, a story...
- alkonaut 10y agoI smell some sacrasm. When I say "FPS" I mean that as a distinct category from a shooter with RPG elements, cover based shooters, etc. Ok the Q2 story was perhaps thin, but have you played todays fps'es? (CoD/BF/...)
- throwanem 10y agoI guess it depends? When I say "FPS" I mean anything from Doom to System Shock 2 - if it's a first-person view and the primary means of interacting with the world is via weapons, it counts as an FPS by me. I guess I'd call stuff like what you're talking about "pure FPS", but apparently that's the name of a specific dev studio with a very poor reputation, so who knows.
- bitwize 10y agoDoom had cover; if you aren't using cover in Doom, you're playing it wrong. Use a door as a chokepoint, equip super shotty. Jump out, get a shot off, kill a couple dudes, jump back into cover as you reload, repeat. Or how about the Cyberdemon fight? It's not just "shoot it until it dies" because you do not want to be wide open in that battle unless you're an expert circlestrafer; you want to use the columns in the level to your advantage. What Doom and Quake lacked was "press B to kneel behind this waist-height wall". But I don't think that's really an improvement. Getting into and out of cover was janky in every game I played that had that mechanic (Mass Effect, Uncharted, Final Fantasy XV?!). And you were vulnerable unless the game recognized you as being behind cover (until the enemies flanked you that is). Plus there's the effect of "oh boy! Waist height walls! Gee, I wonder if a battle is coming up?" The point is, the core gameplay of Doom and Quake was nuts, and was never quite replicated in any of the modern shooters (sorry Doom 2016, you were fun though). The game would drop you in a level full of things wanting to murder you and let you figure out how to survive. Many of the things you mentioned are bolt-on extensions to the gameplay that make it seem deeper, but may make it actually shallower because they constrain how you interact with the world; note also how Doom and Quake lack linear, corridor-like levels and "Return to the Combat Area"...
- KON_Air 10y agoCover is for the weak, you can circle around slow projectiles and hitscan enemies will not waste shots when you are in cover. And shooting cyberdemon until it dies is the only way to kill it.
- Anthony-G 10y agoI used to enjoy circling around a cyberdemon and only shooting at it with the double-barrelled shotgun from Doom 2. I can't remember how many shots it took to kill it. The shotgun blasts were less effective from the safe range (couldn't get too close to a cyberdemon) but still packed a punch.
- mercer 10y agoSerious Sam did a pretty decent job recreating the experience of Doom.
- bitwize 10y agoThat's what a lot of people think, and that's what the Doom 2016 developers thought -- but it's not true. Serious Sam and Painkiller are games where you walk to a new wide-open area (way wide in SS) and dudes spawn that you have to kill before leaving the area. Don't get me wrong, this is fun. But Doom was different even from this. In Classic Doom, the whole map is available right from the start, and every monster already exists in the level. Enemies can sight and chase you from one end of the map to the other if they're alerted and nothing gets in the way. Plus, the haphazard map layout is confusing and disorienting. You really have to overcome and manage the terrain in order to beat back the demon hordes.
- cableshaft 10y agoSerious Sam? Don't you mean "Running Backwards While Shooting: The Game"?