4 ms·
Preface: I'm British. It's very trendy to hate on the monarchy, rationally it makes sense but if we look at the numbers they bring in more money to the country
by dijit 10y ago
Preface: I'm British.
It's very trendy to hate on the monarchy, rationally it makes sense but if we look at the numbers they bring in more money to the country than they take out, Elizabeth evokes a sort of stability in our politics and it's not certain how those affects are felt.
To take the words from Stephen Fry: "It is rational to assume that countries without a constitutional monarchy are freeer, however, the countries which are freeest are Denmark, Norway, Sweden- and they have a monarchy."
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=eJQHakkViPo https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=eJQHakkViPo
- cmurf 10y agoDefine free. What's the exact metric for this ranking? It sounds quite a bit more complex and even nebulous than who makes the best butter. I do like this part, "Mrs. Tony Blair was raised in a working-class family in Liverpool and became a successful barrister. Snobbery: the British disease." There's something weirdly similar here, where a fairly huge chunk of working class voted for the person born with $million in his pocket, and quite literally hate the woman born into a working class family and actually worked for most of her life (and was the bread winner) up until heading to D.C. It's almost a kind of self-hate variety of snobbery.
- arethuza 10y agoThat part isn't true though - Blair went to private schools, notably the elite Fettes College as a boarder. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tony_Blair#Education https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tony_Blair#Education The idea that anyone typically "working class" went to Fettes in the late 1960s is rather amusing - it is still rather grand to this day. Edit: The reasons for the widespread hatred of Blair in the UK have nothing to do with his background. Edit2: Apologies - I misread, not used to reading "Mrs Tony Blair"....
- brucelidl 10y agoThe quote is referring to Cherie Blair, not Tony.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- dijit 10y ago>Define free. the Human Freedom index[0] is a good start, which is littered at the top with monarchies. (although, there are also some republics like Switzerland/Hong Kong) [0]: https://object.cato.org/sites/cato.org/files/human-freedom-index-files/human-freedom-index-2016.pdf https://object.cato.org/sites/cato.org/files/human-freedom-i...
- gvd 10y agoThere is a cause/causation issue BUT it does so happen to be that these countries have a: high living standard, little inequality, rank high on press freedom, high upward mobility. These monarchies also have very little to no power, so an argument against them, other than the financial burden, usually doesn't hold.
- cafard 10y agoWhich woman would that be who was born into a working class family?
- dangravell 10y agoTrendy to hate on the monarchy? Doesn't sound like the UK in 2016. 1996 maybe!
- dijit 10y agoAbsolutely not. Listen to any talk "down the pub" about the monarchy. It is extremely unlikely you'll hear anything positive. (Unless it's New Year's Eve when everyone has a shared "proud to be British" sentiment.)
- new299 10y agoHonest question: Can you name a public figure that people down the pub do say positive things about?
- dijit 10y agoStephen Fry. Nigel Farage (typically, ugh). David Attenborough The Actor who plays Mrs Brown in Mrs Browns Boys. The British monarchy as individuals (excluding Charles)
- dangravell 10y agoI think we go to some different pubs.
- martiuk 10y agoAh, yes. The trendy hip pubs with attached microbrewery.
- jondubois 10y agoYes I think it helps to dilute power at the top - This is especially true for countries like Australia where the queen (through her Governor General) literally has the power to remove the elected Prime Minister. It keeps them on their toes.