6 ms·
Say why could t you use an electric field instead of a magnetic field?
by mrfusion 10y ago
Say why could t you use an electric field instead of a magnetic field?
- _tvei 10y agoApologies if this is a stupid question but aren't they the same thing?
- gliese1337 10y agoNope. They are both part of the same thing - the joint electromagnetic field - and they transform into each other in different reference frames, but in a given reference frame, the electric field and magnetic field components behave quite differently.
- DennisP 10y agoIt blew my mind when I learned how magnetism is a consequence of special relativity.
- gliese1337 10y agoYou can. That's what a Farnsworth fusor does (there are other related designs, but that's the original, and the kind you can build in your garage). But for complicated reasons, it just isn't efficient enough to actually produce net power output. Of course, neither is any other design right now, but magnetic confinement appears to be the more promising path forward.
- mrfusion 10y agoThanks for the explanation. I looked up some of those designs. Now I'm really puzzled why no one has tried a more naive approach. I'm picturing a hollow metal sphere with a high positive charge with positive ions inside of it. Wouldn't it push them all together and with a high enough charge get them hot enough to fuse?
- tedsanders 10y agoCounterintuitively, this setup would have zero force inside the sphere. It turns out that being closer to charge on one side of the sphere is always exactly balanced out by the more distant side's greater total charge.