4 ms·
Is it true that this reactor doesn't use the latest REBCO superconductors? I watched a talk where they claim they can make reactors 10x smaller now, because the
by visarga 10y ago
Is it true that this reactor doesn't use the latest REBCO superconductors? I watched a talk where they claim they can make reactors 10x smaller now, because they increased the strength of the magnetic field (can go up to 10-20T, instead of 3T). And the superconducting tape is cheap, much more flexible and only needs to be cooled to 100K instead of 4K.
If that's true and I'm not mistaken, the MIT ARC reactor would be much better posed to win the race than Wendelstein 7-X, especially that W7X doesn't aim to generate surplus energy. A commenter above was wondering at the expensive diamond window they had to use. This project is going to be too expensive and with dated technology. We could do it cheaper now.
- buster 10y agoThe projects goal is not to build a reactor but to study plasma physics. I'd guess the diamond window is surely industrial diamonds. Fun fact as well: There are inner plates for shielding which are screwed into place. The question is: So you have a shield to protect from very high temperatures but also a screw on the same side. How do you protect the screw? You put a diamond coating over it. :) Also, of course we could do it cheaper now. The project began around 20 years ago and had much luck, because there were many occassions were the techhnology needed to build the Wendelstein was just invented. Source: A german 2h30m podcast with the project lead: https://alternativlos.org/36/ https://alternativlos.org/36/ Extremely interesting!
- Quanttek 10y agoThey started 2003 with the construction. Of course it can be built cheaper and more efficient know, but in 10 years you could again write the same comment about dated technology and cost. In that sense, the project is using up-to-date technology as there is no other similar stellarator running with newer technology. > This project is going to You seem to imply it's still in construction. It's finished already, in fact they finished testing it a year ago.
- mioelnir 10y agoThe design for ITER was finalized in 2001, amended in 2007. Construction for W7-X started 2003. W7-X is now built, fully functional and operational. At several points during its construction, the construction process for its required parts had to be invented first. That's 15+ years of research, breakthroughs and inventions in plasma confinement physics and engineering that have had to happen first. As a noncommercial research reactor, W7-X will continue to be useful for many years to come. For material testing alone I would imagine access to reactor capable of producing a stable, continuous fusion reaction is invaluable. The ARC is a design proposal from 2015. As such they have access and can utilize all the achievements, results and processes from W7-X, ITER and other material science advances of the last 15 years. If their proposal was not better than already built specimens, it would be a bad proposal. To declare it a race against the research foundation they built upon seems ignorant at best. In 10-20 years, when the ARC is built, a new design proposal will emerge, based on even newer advances in material science and the lessons learned from building the ARC. And it again will be better than the then current, assembled reactors. That is how it is supposed to be.
- visarga 10y agoBut, the catch is that ARC reactor is smaller, cheaper, faster to build and could possibly be developed by industry, which would speed up the research cycle.
- revelation 10y agoW7X isn't a reactor. It is not even fusion. It's just plasma physics research.