3 ms·
Thanks for posting this. I like this a lot and it clearly argues a lot of what I don't like about Stallman's free software advocacy. Free software isn't a moral
by geofft 10y ago
Thanks for posting this. I like this a lot and it clearly argues a lot of what I don't like about Stallman's free software advocacy. Free software isn't a moral good in itself, and non-free software isn't a moral evil in itself; software is a tool for accomplishing things in the world, including moral or immoral things. When Stallman says that it's better to have no software to do a task than non-free software, it sounds like the Catholic teaching on intrinsically evil acts, which can never be done even if we think they may result in good—but software does not have a moral value of its own. What we do with software is, absolutely, a moral question; as software continues to eat the world, every moral question may one day involve software. But we should look at software freedom with consequentialist eyes: the ends, the good or evil done to people, justify or condemn the means, whether that good or evil can be done with the software at hand. Generally one can do more good, or at least be assured of fighting evil, with free software. But that does not mean that free software itself is an intrinsic moral good.
Related, I think, is Mako's 2011 essay "Freedom for Users, Not for Software": http://wealthofthecommons.org/essay/freedom-users-not-software http://wealthofthecommons.org/essay/freedom-users-not-softwa...
But in practice, that ends up being more of a defense of the AGPL than a call for social action - and the AGPL, if widely adopted, would make the goal of using only free software even more of a burden (since it is GPL-incompatible). The FSF seemed to recognize an actual problem well worth solving, but address it through the tool they were comfortable with, writing licenses. (And the minimal adoption of the AGPL indicates that this didn't actually solve problems, so per consequentialism, we must admit that the AGPL did at most minimal social good.)
It's also worth talking about the resources required to make effective use of free software; freedom #4 is only realistic if you can actually make the changes. If Chrome OS (to take Mako's example) can be effectively hacked on by the second-largest company in the world, but much less effectively by an individual, is that really better than the closed-source OS which only the largest company in the world can hack on? And has free software really changed the social order for the better, compared to the pre-software days?
- milesrout 10y ago>Free software isn't a moral good in itself, and non-free software isn't a moral evil in itself; I disagree. Proprietary software is anti-user and anti-developer. In my experience, even the sort of people that don't care either way about whether their operating system is open source get upset at the idea of the View Source button on a webpage going away, for example. Free software is ethically good in comparison to proprietary software, which is definitely ethically bad in its own right.
- icebraining 10y agoI think the argument in your first paragraph mostly misses the mark: yes, software is a tool, but Stallman doesn't actually criticize the software, he criticizes the way it is licensed to people. And his analysis does have a consequentialist component - he discusses at length the actual harmful effects of non-free software.
- krapp 10y agoRegarding freedom 4, I've always assumed (possibly erroneously) that Stallman envisioned "software" as being limited more or less exclusively to Unixlike C programs. It really doesn't make a lot of sense as an axiom if you assume software will eventually become too complex to be comprehensible to a single individual, or that the typical software user won't require a working knowledge of CS and C compiler and be able to edit and compile from source.
- icebraining 10y agoI really disagree with this view that one has to have the skill to understand and edit the code to benefit the Four Freedoms. The fact that everyone who gets a copy has that Freedom is the important part. How many use Cyanogenmod without even knowing what a compiler is? How would that be possible without Freedom #4?
- krapp 10y agoUsers can't benefit from the fourth freedom, specifically the right to republish their own modifications to their own software, without having the skill to understand and edit that software to begin with.
- BuuQu9hu 10y agoYou are ignoring the fact that users exist in society, around them there will be programmers who may be friends, colleagues or consultants. Some of those will be willing to modify the software gratis, for a favour or for money. Others will be willing to teach the non-programmers enough to be able to make the changes they need.
- prodigal_erik 10y agoThis. You wouldn't want a car with the hood welded shut. You can take it to a third-party mechanic rather than being at the mercy of the dealer (who would prefer you replace the car), and that's valuable even if you don't have the knowledge or tools to repair the car personally.