3 ms·
We see these studies every few years. I think it's really just a publication bias issue. If a result of a study is that vitamins do what they're supposed to why
by mrfusion 10y ago
We see these studies every few years. I think it's really just a publication bias issue. If a result of a study is that vitamins do what they're supposed to why would you publish that? Why would the media report on that?
- contingencies 10y agoOr maybe half the studies are funded by drug companies who enjoy profiteering? The 'average' person (no medical knowledge, no access to research journals, no background knowledge to interpret them) has no way to know. Society should welcome measured criticism, especially from the likes of BBC science journalists, as a counterbalance to constantly advertised commercial interests.
- slaveofallah93 10y agoNo drug company owns a patent on vitamin C. And this BBC article is barely above clickbait journalism. Don't pretend like this is some example of great high quality science reporting.
- contingencies 10y agoIt's not bad. Nutraceuticals didn't invent themselves.
- pessimizer 10y agoYou would publish that because there's a vast industry that sells and advertises vitamins? The publication bias leans vastly in the opposite direction than you're intuiting here.
- kitbrennan 10y agoThe publication bias would go in the other direction. A drug company showing the effectiveness of vitamin pills would publish that research to help them sell more vitamin pills; A drug company finding vitamin pills to be ineffective would be incentivised to not publish the research. Further more, we're not talking about just one study here against a sea of studies in favour of vitamin supplements. Free radical theory has been shown to be effective in a petridish, but it has a neutral or negative effect in most large scale human studies.