3 ms·
> the known universe would be a black hole if its mass was concentrated in the center The universe doesn't have a "center". The universe did have a much higher
by pdonis 10y ago
> the known universe would be a black hole if its mass was concentrated in the center
The universe doesn't have a "center". The universe did have a much higher density right after the Big Bang, but it was expanding rapidly; that's why it was (and is) not a black hole.
> Is there anything we know makes my idea impossible?
Yes, the fact that it's based on a misconception about the universe's spacetime geometry. See above.
There are certainly "bounce" models being considered for what preceded the Big Bang (although they're by no means the only models being considered). But they don't work like what you are describing.
- m_mueller 10y agoMy point is that the way the universe works, i.e. spacetime expansion, inflation and acceleration (dark energy) could all be governed by processes inside a black hole's singularity - something we afaik don't have a good model yet. It's only a black hole from the reference point of the parent universe. I don't mean the old bounce model, more like bubbles around a water hose that get smaller the farther away from the source - i.e a stellar black hole creates a mini universe through its own spacetime rip.
- pdonis 10y ago> My point is that the way the universe works, i.e. spacetime expansion, inflation and acceleration (dark energy) could all be governed by processes inside a black hole's singularity The singularity doesn't have an "inside". See below. > something we afaik don't have a good model yet The models that are being looked at get rid of the singularity altogether. They don't try to model it as being made up of internal parts. > a stellar black hole creates a mini universe through its own spacetime rip. Some physicists have considered models in which black holes give birth to "baby universes" (Hawking and Lee Smolin are two that come to mind). But these models don't "rip" spacetime; they remove the singularity, which in the standard classical GR model is just a spacelike surface--a moment of time--that represents a boundary of spacetime, and instead just extend the spacetime further on, into the spacetime of the new universe.