2 ms·
No I don't mean for my comment to deliver emotional impact or to be carried through vehicles of sarcasm or irony. And whether Scotland becomes independent, my
by threatofrain 10y ago
No I don't mean for my comment to deliver emotional impact or to be carried through vehicles of sarcasm or irony.
And whether Scotland becomes independent, my point remains -- you can ask why Amazon pays minimum wage, or you can ask why minimum wage is so low.
Depending on Amazon to be moral is as inadequate a solution as hoping for noblesse oblige. It's more interesting to discuss the <mechanics> of why Amazon class entities will pay higher wages.
Or people can morally shame <one> Amazon event, just like people who disagreed with Peter Thiel's influence in the sex tape case instinctually shame <one> Peter Thiel event. Whether you're asking for Amazon or Peter Thiel to "do the right thing", you're asking for noblesse oblige.
This kind of moral shaming does not scale, it depends on flash outrage, and companies that play the long game in media will beat this kind of ad-hoc moral shaming.
I also wanted to discuss not merely government structure, but also social structure, to imply that multiple parties need to fail for classes of workers to be exploited. The net of your society is the reason why Amazon is permitted to exploit an individual, and that includes churches, advocacy organizations, unions, etc.
I thought that discussion of both hard and soft structures is the better way to go, or we can hope that outrage continues to shows up at the right time and the right place.
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoNo, we can ask why any profitable large corporation thinks its ok to pay starvation wages to their workers. Its not right; they have the money to pay more; they don't. I'm asking why.
- threatofrain 10y agoIs it right for you to have drinking water delivered through modern technologies and systems? Is that your moral right? Should we discuss whether you have the moral right to water, or should we discuss the formal plans to erect an infrastructure of water? The latter doesn't require you to do any serious moral labor (deliberation and consensus work). You need only want. Do we both want something? Then we already have a basis for discussion. The question of whether you want workers to be paid more is far easier to answer than the question of whether moral consensus on workers wages can be achieved in your lifespan. Also, how many moral frameworks for achieving moral consensus are you aware of? There are certainly frameworks for achieving empirical consensus on policy effectiveness.
- prostoalex 10y agoHow would more money improve the situation described (besides a fancier tent)? We have no indication there was any real estate for sale or other lodging opportunities nearby. For what it's worth, the land in that rural area might not be zoned residential or have proper infrastructure (roads, heat, gas, water, sewage). The person has a house and could already commute from far out, they chose not to.