6 ms·
Unconscionable Public Education Practices
- a2tech 17y agoThe public school system in the United States is a wonderful undertaking. Unfortunately it is deeply flawed and in its current state does a great disservice to the students that attend school within the public system. My wife works with undergraduate students at a major university every single day and she is a first hand witness to the poor quality of public education nationwide. The students that she encounters are often woefully unprepared for a college education-they have a poor grasp of written English, have low reading comprehension and their grasp of basic mathematical skills is better left unexplored. These students ARE NOT the bottom of the barrel either-the admission system filters most of them out. Its a very sad state of affairs. Our children will be attending private school-even though I don't agree with their religion (most private schools here are Catholic) I can't argue with their results. My wife left her private high school with English, math and science skills that rival most college graduates.
- sketerpot 17y agoI apologize for being That Guy, and your comment's content was very nice, but hyphens should not be used to separate words -- for that, you should use longer dashes. You can imitate this in plain text with the string " -- ". This makes your words easier to read, since using a single hyphen makes it look like you're just using hyphenated-words. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dash http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dash (Back on topic, my public school education never mentioned this. I learned it from the documentation for LaTeX. A sad state of affairs.)
- grandalf 17y agoIt's important to differentiate between public funding and public provisioning of public education. Public funding might mean that a kid from a less wealthy family could afford to attend a private school via a grant from the state. Public provisioning means that schools ultimately have more in common with the DMV than with elite educational institutions. Public schools are intended to be daycare centers for the poor and middle class, so that women can join the work force without having to care for their children during the day. The goal of public schools is to teach children to conform to the expectations of the work force, so depending on where the school is located the students may end up barely literate but sufficient to fill the local factory jobs, etc. It's important to keep this in mind when thinking about public education. Public schools have not failed, they are succeeding quite well at what they are actually intended to accomplish. Some public schools (those in rich suburbs) actually provide a good education (chances are someone who attended one of those schools will object to this comment). Those are an exception and exist in areas where residents could afford to send their kids to private school if necessary.
- pw0ncakes 17y agoSome public schools (those in rich suburbs) actually provide a good education (chances are someone who attended one of those schools will object to this comment). Those are an exception and exist in areas where residents could afford to send their kids to private school if necessary. I think a few things are worth pointing out here: The best 10-20% of teachers are really good, because teaching is (although not as admired as medicine or law) admired enough that some seriously talented people enter it. Those teachers are highly desired and usually end up at the most reputable schools teaching honors and AP classes. So if you're lucky enough to have such teachers, you're going to get a good education. Good schools have no problem getting a satisfactory percentage of students to pass the assessment tests and therefore actually teach. Mediocre schools that are on the bubble begin "teaching to the test" (which means a focus of attention and resources onto the worst students, to the detriment of average and good students) and therefore the quality of education declines even further.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- yummyfajitas 17y agoFocusing attention/resources onto the worst students will raise the median/mean quality of education at the expense of the quality of the 90'th percentile. For an egalitarian [1], this should probably be a good thing. [1] I use the word "egalitarian" in the liberal sense of favoring equal outcomes for all people/groups.
- grandalf 17y agoI think you make an accurate point that people who teach (who are capable enough to have other options) are probably not motivated solely by the financial rewards. But there is nothing about teaching that would prevent a top teacher from earning $250K per year. The reason that doesn't happen (and the reason we don't see more luxury cars in the teachers' parking long) is because unions have forced wages to be based on seniority and not based on merit. This means that rather than one teacher (a good one) making $70K and another (not so good one) making $30K, they both make $50K. This gives the bad teacher every incentive to continue being a mediocre teacher for decades rather than moving on and finding a career he/she is good at.
- SamAtt 17y agoBefore I say this let me just say that I'm not defending LAUSD and I do think there are better ways they could be doing things. But as someone who lives in the area there's more story here. Budget cuts have brought the LAUSD to the point where classes are literally 50+% fuller than they should be. That's at least 45 kids in class rooms designed for 30. You go into one of these classrooms and you'll find kids sitting on the floor or one kid in a folding chair sharing a traditional desk with the other kid who is actually sitting in the desk. As atrocious as some of the behavior in the article seems it's been brought about by the hard reality of there being no place for these kids to go even if the school did hold them back. (For frame of reference LAUSD had a budget deficit of around $894 million last year which is about $1,290 per student) I have many criticisms of public schools in the U.S. but this isn't about that. This is about 3 Government bodies (Federal, State and Local) that all spent way more than they could afford on trivial things and now have no money left to do what's important.
- euroclydon 17y agoThanks for the marginal information, but according to Wikipedia, the total LAUSD budget for 2008-2009 was $13,645,600,000. Divided by 700,000 pupils comes out to $19,493 per student!!!
- SamAtt 17y agoI don't really see your point. The reality is that money is going to other places. Most notably Pension payments (http://www.atr.org/californias-billion-pension-bomb-a4786# http://www.atr.org/californias-billion-pension-bomb-a4786#). Keep in mind teachers can retire after 25 years but continue to get about 65k a year indefinitely plus Medical, Dental, etc. I don't know where the number is now but in 2006 the city would have needed $10 billion to cover its pension costs and it didn't have that then: http://www.thefreelibrary.com/LAUSDS+RUNAWAY+BENEFITS+PRICE+TAG+RETIREE+EXPENSES+PUT+AT+$10...-a0142222213 http://www.thefreelibrary.com/LAUSDS+RUNAWAY+BENEFITS+PRICE+... I think that's ridiculous and I don't think they ever should have been given that kind of deal but the School District is still contractually obligated to pay those pensions. The city of Vallejo actually tried to declare bankruptcy because it couldn't afford the enormous debt generated by pensions and the result was the California Legislature voting to exempt pension payments from city bankruptcy.
- euroclydon 17y agoIf you read The Underground History of American Education, an opus of a book compiled over thirty years by John Gatto (former NY and NYC teacher of the year), you will learn that over a hundred years ago, powerful industrialists sought to shape the public educational system around Darwinian Evolution. What this means is that they believed that most poor children were, as evidenced by their poor status, lesser life forms, and that the school's job was essentially to destroy them, and among other things, remove them from competition for breeding. Free online: http://www.johntaylorgatto.com/chapters/index.htm http://www.johntaylorgatto.com/chapters/index.htm
- briancooley 17y agoBut what is the message that students get from social promotion? How about that there is no incentive to learn An educational system that incentivizes learning via fear of failure (public humiliation in this case) is broken. This false dichotomy of social promotion versus holding students back ignores the necessity of finding new ways to engage struggling students. Of course promoting kids to face material for which they are not prepared is going to be a problem. But having them repeat the material in the same manner and expecting them to catch on the second time around is lunacy as well. The biggest problem that I see in education is the focus on measuring achievement in an easily-measured, narrowly-defined way. That such a system has become gamed to the point that even the successful students aren't really learning should be no surprise. What's the solution? I know there aren't easy answers, but it has to start with making learning and teaching fun. The happiest moment in a teacher's day is when the light switches on for a student. Though it is cliche, learning is fun, but the caveat is that it's the most fun when the lesson is applied.
- btilly 17y agoAn educational system that incentivizes learning via fear of failure (public humiliation in this case) is broken. While nobody likes to fail, failure is not important mostly as a means of motivation. It is important because repetition often helps. You claim that it is lunacy to expect that a second go will solve problems. Yet that "lunacy" has worked out pretty well for people I know who had to retake courses and grades. The second time through, usually with different teachers, the students learned. Part of it was the age advantage. Part of it was a different teacher. Part of it was the fact that if you halfway learn the first time, there is less to learn the second time. Taking failure off the table out of excessive concern for hurting fragile feelings does everyone a disservice. And is a far greater lunacy than being willing to tell people, "You haven't learned this material, you need to try again."
- briancooley 17y agoTaking failure off the table out of excessive concern for hurting fragile feelings does everyone a disservice There's more at stake than students' hurt feelings. Your anecdotes aside, statistics show that retaining students is expensive and largely ineffective [1]. What's most dangerous to me is the idea that without the threat of failure there is no incentive to learn. That's a viewpoint that deserves scrutiny. It's narrow-minded and serves mostly to blame the student. It also closes the door to examination of alternative ways to best serve the section of the student body most likely to be considered for social promotion. The other side of the spectrum is standardized testing, which places the blame on teachers and encourages them to narrow their focus to material that will be on the test. And it's all built around proving that students can fill in the right circles on a standardized test, such that even the successful ones aren't guaranteed to be able to do practical things (e.g. CS majors that can't write a program). The bottom line is that we are not really teaching. More importantly, we are not teaching kids how to learn, which is the key to motivated students. [1] http://www.ssc.wisc.edu/cde/cdewp/99-06.pdf http://www.ssc.wisc.edu/cde/cdewp/99-06.pdf
- vinhboy 17y agoThe real problem with public education: the parents. You can't teach kids who come home to parents who do not value education. An oversized classroom is not as bad as students who have no interested and no motivation to learn. But it's not the student fault, it's their parents. Sad thing is, it's kind of an endless cycle. Maybe we should punish the parents... but I don't know how well that would work either...
- brg 17y agoWhen parents are almost entirely removed from the education process, without input into curriculum[1] or teacher selection[2], can you blame many for becoming disinterested bystandards? In private religious and secular schools, I have noticed that parental involvement is much higher. [1] Set at the state and national level as a result of funding. [2] In many locales, set by unions and un-elected administration.
- feverishaaron 17y agoWhenever you tie student test scores to national standards, which affect funding, and thus compensation, this is what you get.
- stcredzero 17y agoA second practice involves teachers doing students' work for them just so students can pass the class...In a Bizarro world, this practice would be win-win From everything I've seen, big bureaucracies are Bizarro World.
- jashmenn 17y agoIt's sometimes worse than this article describes and it's not just in LA. I grew up in a small town in NH (population ~5k people). I have a close friend whose sister was in a "special attention" program (let's call her Jane). Jane was in a program for kids who were "slower" than the other kids. They didn't have any physical learning disabilities, just poorer grades. The time came for the yearly standardized tests (called the CATs in NH). On the day of the tests Jane's class was taken out on a special 'field trip'; they all went bowling. In the morning the kids lined up for class and Jane and her friends gloated to the other suckers who had to stay behind, "We get to go bowling and you have to stay here and take tests." The result? The school's scores were a little bit higher that year.
- wdewind 17y agoI would look at this from an even higher, more abstract level than budgets. It's a bit of a chicken or egg problem, but I went to what are considered some of the best public schools in NYC growing up, and I can tell you they aren't great. From a quick look they have all the right check boxes: experienced teachers (close look: old, tired, angry teachers), great math, science and humanities programs (rigid, standardized test based curriculum), etc. etc. The education I got was by all means "good," but it was VERY herd mentality, and it as very much about standardizing a body of knowledge and culture NOT about promoting active discourse etc. Yet, I still ended up alright, whereas, considering how "good" a high school I went to, many of the kids did not. The difference was the home, the neighborhood and the culture we went home to at night. Now I know all of this is circular, and a bit of the chicken egg issue, but there is really nothing you can do for people when the household they go back to doesn't support their education. Conversely, even a horrible school can't ruin a good education provided by your family and community. You can give them all the help in the world, but no matter how many free college workshops you have, if education isn't explicitly a goal among their friends, family and community they'll realize pretty quickly that it wont be useful in their lives and will disengage. So I'm all for education reform, I think it should be a constant in our society. Education ALWAYS needs improving. But we need to be a little more careful with understanding what exactly an education system can and cannot provide. The problems that are in this article can't really be fixed with a better education system, they are symptomatic of far bigger cultural issues that need addressing.