3 ms·
Why are these people working for Amazon if it's so bad and what would they be doing if it were not for Amazon? It's not like they're conscripting workers in the
by koolba 10y ago
Why are these people working for Amazon if it's so bad and what would they be doing if it were not for Amazon? It's not like they're conscripting workers in the dead of the night and shackling them to the warehouse. I'm not saying there shouldn't be labor rules, work week hours, etc, but if they're not breaking any laws what's the big deal?
Every few months we see articles about programmers working at $SILICON_VALLEY_BIG_CORP that lives in a van outside the office or sleeps under his desk at night. The worker is usually a combination of frugal and nutty. What's the difference between that and this?
- SolaceQuantum 10y agoJust because they may have nothing else doesn't mean it's not deplorable.
- throwaway729 10y agoFrom the article: > He added that he had opted to stay in a tent as it was easier and cheaper than commuting from his home in Perth, although his camping equipment had disappeared by Friday afternoon.
- tedunangst 10y agoSee? Problem solved. Now he gets to go home and everything is better.
- gsnedders 10y agoFor those with no idea about the geography of this part of the world: it's about a 30 minute drive down the motorway, and from memory congestion only gets particularly bad further south on it at rush hour, so even at rush hour it won't be that much longer. Of course, the big difference with the programmer under the desk is the programmer is unlikely to be earning minimum wage. Anyone 25 and over, working 60 hours a week at minimum wage, is earning £432/week. If we assume they're working those hours or on vacation all year, their take home pay is £355/week. If we assume fuel costs of ~£4.50 each way, then if they're working five days a week that's ~13% of their income, or if six days ~15%.
- adevine 10y agoYeah, why don't they just get a job paying twice as much where they don't have to sleep in a tent? Silly peasants. And how is a Google software engineering making six figures, sleeping in a van in 68 degree California, any different from a minimum wage worker sleeping in a tent in a field in the middle-of-winter Scotland?
- koolba 10y ago> Yeah, why don't they just get a job paying twice as much where they don't have to sleep in a tent? Silly peasants. And how is a Google software engineering making six figures, sleeping in a van in 68 degree California, any different from a minimum wage worker sleeping in a tent in a field in the middle-of-winter Scotland? If the circumstances are so dire that the worker has no other choices for employment, the alternative is no employment at all. That's the baseline comparison point for whatever job Amazon is providing and the worker always has that option as well. Amazon is not a charity, it's a for-profit company, and arguably by building the warehouse and providing jobs it's doing more long term good than a charity would by handing out sandwiches. Comments like yours bring to mind the phrase "No good deed goes unpunished". Would they be better off with no jobs at all?
- adevine 10y agoI'm kind of amazed by the basest level of empathy that seems to be missing among many in our industry. I'm not even arguing what the right solution is - that is certainly debatable. But given how good we have it as software engineers, when someone's best option is to sleep in a tent for their work, and we comment "how is that any different from someone making twenty times as much voluntarily choosing to live in a van?", it sounds awful close to "Let them eat cake."
- berntb 10y agoI am not an economist but Krugman is, a left leaning one at that which spent a large time arguing against Bush/Trump. And he is arguing a similar position: http://www.slate.com/articles/business/the_dismal_science/1997/03/in_praise_of_cheap_labor.html http://www.slate.com/articles/business/the_dismal_science/19... (This is getting close to politics, a really tiresome subject which happily is banned right now on HN.)
- paulddraper 10y agoI appreciated the suggestion given elsewhere for the title "Amazon gives jobs to local homeless population"