5 ms·
> The point is that while such technologies are useful for finding good information, they can also greatly magnify any damage caused by bad information. A searc
by lisper 10y ago
> The point is that while such technologies are useful for finding good information, they can also greatly magnify any damage caused by bad information. A search engine that links to a newspaper article describing how someone was accused of rape won't necessarily also link to the follow-up article describing how the key witness later admitted in court that they made the whole thing up and was found guilty of perjury themselves. And yet, a prospective employer or girlfriend or whoever else might have reason to look that person up by name won't know that and might reach entirely the wrong conclusion if they only saw the first article.
But the answer to that is not to try to suppress the first article, but rather to draw attention to the second.
But that is really missing the point. If France wants to deal with this issue through censorship that is France's prerogative. The point is that France should not be able to censor information outside its own borders.
- Silhouette 10y agoBut the answer to that is not to try to suppress the first article, but rather to draw attention to the second. You're assuming the second exists, but that is outside the control of sites like search engines that are just linking to others' content. In any case, I don't agree. If the first article is incorrect or misleading, I have no problem with suppressing that article rather than unfairly damaging the person who was described in it. This is not censorship any more than saying you'll arrest someone who shouts "Fire!" in a crowded theatre just to cause a dangerous panic or someone who phones in a false bomb threat just to disrupt a big public event. Words are powerful things. People who abuse their ability to speak and in doing so cause unjust harm to others need to be treated appropriately by the law. People who propagate or perpetuate those harmful words are contributing to the harm themselves and also need to be treated in some appropriate way by the law. The point is that France should not be able to censor information outside its own borders. We agree on the underlying principle here. I wrote a little more about this in my first comment in this HN discussion.
- lisper 10y ago> You're assuming the second exists You stipulated that it did. If it didn't, then on what basis do you determine that the first article is wrong? > We agree on the underlying principle here. Maybe we should just leave it at that.
- Silhouette 10y agoIf it didn't, then on what basis do you determine that the first article is wrong? That brings us back to where we came in: the "right to be forgotten" measures provide a way for someone who is suffering harm as a result of information being spread about them to notify the likes of search engines that that information should not be spread about them. Having been so notified, if the search engine continues to propagate the information anyway, it can't say it wasn't warned and it's on the hook for any harm it causes. It's a similar principle to various other "safe harbour" style laws that have been written in recent years, trying to balance the benefits that derive from having these powerful, automated services available online with the dangers that they inherently bring if they act unfairly or get something wrong. The consensus so far seems to be that such services shouldn't necessarily be on the hook for automatically generated or user-supplied content by default, but making them provide a clear notification mechanism and accept responsibility once they have actual knowledge of something going wrong is a fair trade for that safety net.
- lisper 10y ago> provide a way for someone who is suffering harm as a result of information being spread about them to notify the likes of search engines that that information should not be spread about them Yes, of course. But whether or not an individual should be able to censor true information about themselves, even if that information is harmful to them, is highly debatable. I'm happy to engage in that debate if you want, but that is a different issue than the one which I originally raised, which is the question of whether a country's power to censor should extend beyond its own borders. The answer to that is IMHO an unequivocal "no". (The answer to the question of whether a person should be empowered to censor true information about themselves is also IMHO "no", but that is not nearly so clear-cut. Like I said, if you want to engage on this topic I'm happy to have that debate as well. But let us not conflate the two issues. They need to be kept separate or we will end up in a hopeless muddle.)