4 ms·
I think this is a great situation to quote Linus on Linux supporters inside companies (not 100% same, but I think related): (on litigation against companies th
by izacus 10y ago
I think this is a great situation to quote Linus on Linux supporters inside companies (not 100% same, but I think related):
(on litigation against companies that contribute)
> Anyone in the company that pushed to use Linux is now seen as "wrong" and instantly is pissed off that external people just messed up their employment future.
> - Anyone in the company that resisted the use of Linux (possibly in ways that caused the code not to be released over the objection of the previously mentioned people) are vindicated in their opinion of those "hippy"[2] programmers who develop Linux.
...
> Now, even if, after many years of work on your part, you do get that code, what is the end result? You have made an enemy for life from the people who brought Linux into the company, you have pissed off the people who didn't like Linux in the first place as they were right and yet you "defeated" them. Both of those groups of people will now work together to never use Linux again as they don't want to go through that hell again, no matter what.
(source and context: https://lists.linuxfoundation.org/pipermail/ksummit-discuss/2016-August/003580.html https://lists.linuxfoundation.org/pipermail/ksummit-discuss/... )
...
I think this is the worst part of this SNAFU - Dave has just proven every naysayer in AMD right that Linux is not worth supporting. He cut away feet from the team that has supported and fought for an equivalent opensource driver support on Linux which would be released in lockstep with Windows releases. He has also proven right everyone on nVidia which has talked against opensourcing their drivers and keeping them as a horrendous binary blob. He has also pissed off his greatest ally inside AMD.
All with a single "no". Not "We can't accept this, let's talk about how to make us both happy". With that he gave new ammunition to every manager at every large hardware corporation that's fighting against opensourcing their drivers and made every Linux supporting team lead in such corporation less likely to push opensource world forward. It seems we're stuck in shitty Android kernel forks with shitty GPU binary blobs in near future, with only Windows as a proper contender for good 3D performance.
EDIT: To be clear, I'm not blaming Dave for refusing the patch for tech cases. I AM blaming him for refusing it so flatly and not actively working more with AMD to get the situation fixed. This is not a minor thing - having stable AMD drivers in kernel would really push Linux desktop forward, make sure Linux is compatible with several Macs among other machines and put pressure on nVidia to opensource theirs. But you don't get there by belittling contributors and cultivating "us vs. them" mentality.
- plorkyeran 10y ago> Not "We can't accept this, let's talk about how to make us both happy". He gave them that answer 6 months ago, and they ignored it. This was not an abrupt rejection out of nowhere.
- izacus 10y agoThe "answer" 6 months ago was "Yeah, you'll have to write a full Linux driver yourself and maintain it." type deal. It was unreasonable then as it is now. If I tell you "You need to rewrite your product in Brainfuck or I'll kick you out in 6 months.", the fact that I told you that doesn't make it any less insane.
- serge2k 10y ago> I can respect your technical points and if you kept it to that, I'd be fine with it and we could have a technical discussion starting there. Why is that so unreasonable?
- quickben 10y agoBy the look of it, he's trying to be reasonable now; after half a year of hope that the code will just get checked in because it's coming from AMD, regardless of quality. If I recall correctly, Google tried the same thing some time ago and it didn't go well for them either.
- prodigal_erik 10y agoAMD is trying to merge a Windows driver with enough shims to make it sort of interact with Linux. That might as well be written in Brainfuck from the point of view of a Linux kernel hacker trying to figure out WTF it does. To merge a driver into the kernel is to accept responsibility for maintaining it, which they recognize they are not prepared or even interested in doing.
- makomk 10y ago