5 ms·
There can be pernicious motives whether a facility is nominally for profit or not. (For instance, say there is a doctor who gets paid in proportion to the time
by maxerickson 10y ago
There can be pernicious motives whether a facility is nominally for profit or not.
(For instance, say there is a doctor who gets paid in proportion to the time they spend treating patients at a non profit facility)
- DashRattlesnake 10y agoThat's true, but removing the profit motive of the facility removes one major incentive for coordinated, large scale corruption like this. Other incentives (like production-based compensation being gamed by unscrupulous individuals) will have to be dealt with in other ways.
- sageikosa 10y agoSo without profit, the operating metric will be what exactly?
- danso 10y agoEr...are you questioning the existential purposes of the non-profit sector in general, or just non-profit healthcare?
- sageikosa 10y agoJust trying to point out that human action without profit requires something else to account for the costs; otherwise there is no way to judge comparatively how limited resources should be applied. So if there isn't going to be profit driven activity, what will be the metric for success? If it is "outcomes", then we should start plowing everything we've got into it. Of course, should that mean we stop plowing resources into other endeavors? Do we make a vote of it? A law case?
- bandrami 10y agoIn healthcare we have this amazing thing called "outcomes".
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- gurneyHaleck 10y agoI can see it now: "This graph depicting revenue reveals that the maternity ward is quite the cost center. It should be going up and to the right! Smithers, why are there so few pregnancies? We need more in-patients, otherwise our overhead starts eating away at our profits." "Well, sir, I suppose there aren't as many teen pregnancies as there used to be, and with the benefit of modern procedures, the pregnancies we do see are fairly uncomplicated..." "Uncomplicated?! Why, everyone knows live vaginal births are the devil's causeway. Those infants can't be as healthy as these so- called 'doctors' seem to believe. See to it that more tests are performed. I'm sure we can find something wrong with some of these freeloaders." ...enter Dr. Nick. "Hi, everybody!"
- sageikosa 10y agoYou'll just need to have permission before you can get pregnant; cost problem solved (except for the expanding bureaucracy to manage the rules and operations of maternity).
- nommm-nommm 10y agoPatient outcomes?
- omginternets 10y ago>There can be pernicious motives whether a facility is nominally for profit or not. This is colloquially known as "whataboutism". The fact that there are other pernicious motives is completely irrelevant. For-profit medicine constitutes a pernicious motive -- that's the point.
- maxerickson 10y agoWell, I don't agree with that. I see generous salaries as being exactly the same thing as profit (they are just taxed differently). I also have difficulty with the idea that only de facto agents of the state can deliver healthcare (care only available at fixed prices, etc). So my point is that you need external controls regardless of the motivations of the actors inside the institution.
- rounce 10y ago> I also have difficulty with the idea that only de facto agents of the state can deliver healthcare (care only available at fixed prices, etc). It seems that they aren't the only difficulties you have. In a social health-care system, possession of a medical license doesn't entail one's employer. You're more than welcome to set up private practice, though you'll have less chance of the career defining cases, as the majority of patients will not be using your one-man-band practice. Thus many doctors in the UK, split their time between their private practice and public services. The only thing that's "de-facto" is the need to be qualified to treat people.
- maxerickson 10y agoIt's implicit in the argument I replied to that the side practice better not deliver excess economic benefits (profits!) compared to working in the public facilities.
- omginternets 10y agoThis is completely beside the point. "For-profit healthcare" and "well-paid doctors" are distinct concepts. Doctors are still very well-paid in France, for instance. It's just that the hospital isn't expected to turn a profit.
- Spooky23 10y agoPeople associate everything with the hospital and don't realize that doctors are frequently part of independent practices. I remember vividly when my grandmother was in an awful hospital in NYC dying, I found the hospitalist to talk about her situation. He claimed to not Treating her and had no idea who was and directed me to another doctor. Yet he was standing at the station, with my grandmother's chart open with marking that he had just added her condition. He actually told me the truth, but he was sitting there with a stack of files defrauding Medicare. Whatever profit the hospital was or wasn't making, the doctor was ringing his till.
- specialist 10y agoI use the word "incentives".