7 ms·
One of the things that has made me old (52) and crotchety is that I learned Lisp very early in my career. That gave me the ability to see that 99% of "new" tec
by lisper 10y ago
One of the things that has made me old (52) and crotchety is that I learned Lisp very early in my career. That gave me the ability to see that 99% of "new" technologies were really just poor re-inventions of (parts of) Lisp. Even today, Common Lisp -- despite (or, as some would argue, because of) the fact that it hasn't been officially updated in decades is still not only a viable language but one of the best choices for many applications. But no one knows it because it's not the shiny new thing, and even young people still can't seem to get their heads around the fact that the parens are a feature, not a bug. And that makes me grumpy sometimes.
The good part was that I was able to build a very successful career while not having to suffer nearly as much pain as many of my contemporaries. The bad part is that now it's hard to find people to collaborate with. :-(
- bogomipz 10y agoOut of curiosity what flavor/dialect of LISP do you recommend? Common or something else?
- lisper 10y agoI like Common Lisp, and Clozure CL in particular, but it doesn't really matter all that much. The cool kids seem to be using Clojure (with a J, not a Z) nowadays. Pick whatever works for you.
- fulafel 10y agoIsn't there a good big comnunity in Clojure now?
- lisper 10y agoDepends on what you count as "big". If you look at languages used on github, for example: http://githut.info http://githut.info Clojure is doing OK (better than Common Lisp), but not great (worse than Haskell and Emacs lisp).
- mVChr 10y agoNot quite as much activity as Scala either. I think the good thing is that functional languages as a whole aren't going anywhere, it's just that the jobs for them are spread very thin over several languages.
- dragandj 10y agoMaybe because in Clojure you achieve more with less effort :)
- fulafel 10y agoI bet more people are getting paid to do Clojure work on production systems than Haskell or Emacs lisp. That's a really nice web site. It took me a moment to realize it's showing quarterly data (sadly last updated in 2014), and that the ranking is based on the first metric ("number of active repositories").
- jodrellblank 10y agoEven today, Common Lisp is still one of the best choices for many applications. Then why don't people build amazing and popular things with it? I don't mean one or two people build one or two things, but lots of people building lots of things. Nobody uses it, but it's the best choice, can't both be true. And 'nobody uses it' is approximately true. It's not a mainstream JVM language or CLR language, it's not an AWS or Azure or Google Web Services language, it's not used for Linux Kernel, Windows, Oracle, *BSD, SQL databases, No-SQL databases, it's not used where Erlang is, it's not the research language Haskell is, it's not the fun esolang or the long-tail COBOL, it's not the new compiles-to-JavaScript, it's not the back of 3D games or VR engines, it's not behind Amazon's shop or used where Go is. It's not talked about in StackOverflow's most popular languages surveys, or most profitable languages for devs to learn, or most desired by employers. It's not an educational language like it once was. Yet it's "one of the best choices". I simply don't believe it. Any perceived advantages it has, in practise must be a wash.
- nostrademons 10y agoToo much fun to program in. Lisp makes it remarkably easy to extend the language into just what you want it to be...which means that Lisp programmers tend to spend most of their time extending the language into just what they want it to be rather than solving the problem. (Indeed, this is often touted as one of the benefits of Lisp...once you have a suitably well-adapted DSL, the problem solution follows naturally.) Meanwhile, the Java or Go programmer is thinking "this is boring and ugly. Let me finish this problem as quickly as I can so I can go home." So they finish the problem as quickly as they can, and then it's done, and it ships. And people have an incentive to use it rather than tinker with it because nobody really wants to peek under the hood, and the people who do peek under the hood tend to be really dedicated and care a lot about the problem domain because why else would you put up with the language?
- jodrellblank 10y agoThis one I can believe.
- onion2k 10y ago
- chetanahuja 10y ago"That gave me the ability to see that 99% of "new" technologies were really just poor re-inventions of (parts of) Lisp" "But no one knows it..." It'll be really hard to work with a 23 year old with that attitude too.
- lukego 10y ago> And that makes me grumpy sometimes. If you will excuse a moment of cheekiness... Could be that you have cause and effect backwards here: because you are grumpy you are dismissing 99% of other language developers' work as rubbish. Could be that it's less than 99% and you are overlooking some great ideas.
- lisper 10y agoThat's not cheeky, it's a perfectly fair question. Yes, that is certainly possible. And there have been a few cool new ideas that have come along that are not easily subsumed by CL, like Haskell's type system. It's easy to implement Hindley-Milner, but actually using that information to inform the compiler, plus adding laziness as a core language feature, is much harder. But I think the jury is still very much out on whether or not Haskell is really a net win. But the most popular language on github at the moment is Javascript, and there is no question that it is simply a very badly designed Lisp with C syntax. This is not intended to disparage Brendan Eich. He had a week to design and implement something, and under those constraints he did a pretty amazing job. But I can't help but imagine how different the world would be if he had used Scheme as a starting point. Was there something in particular that you had in mind that you think I may have missed?
- gaius 10y agoBut I can't help but imagine how different the world would be if he had used Scheme as a starting point. I've heard that he did in fact use Scheme, but the suits insisted on the whole curly-brackets-and-semicolons thing so they could call it Javascript and piggyback on Sun's marketing efforts.
- _h_o_d_ 10y agoI'm certain lisper [parent] knows these, indeed may well have worked with PG in the past, but for those who don't, here's some useful linky: http://www.paulgraham.com/lisp.html http://www.paulgraham.com/lisp.html