3 ms·
Thinking on it some more, I suspect a major part of the disagreement (regarding power) is the usage of the word power, influence, control in a interchangeable w
by belorn 10y ago
Thinking on it some more, I suspect a major part of the disagreement (regarding power) is the usage of the word power, influence, control in a interchangeable ways.
To take a trivial example from game theory, a seller and a buyer discussing price. In the classic example, the agreed price represent the result of sellers power vs the buyer power. Since its trivial, control, influence and cause-effect reflects the same values, so if the price is low it means the buy both has higher power and more control over the price.
But then we add a second seller. The position of the buyer has increase and we would say that the buyers power has increased. Inter-group competition influence the result, but the buyer aren't in control over how that competition plays out.
Then we add an government entity that adds regulation which incidentally limits supply. This increase the sellers power, but is completely outside the control of the buyer and the seller. This entity has no stake in the outcome of the transaction, derive no power from it, but got full control.
When talking about power disparity, we need to define what resource the groups are competing over, but also acknowledge that it won't tell us anything about who controls the outcome. To do that we need to define cause and effect, and that require more than just looking at the result. As a political matter, I believe that government intervention should focus on power disparity when it impacts the lower levels of Maslow's hierarchy of needs, and it should do so by addressing each individuals need. It should focus on control disparity for everything else.
- pron 10y agoYou are trying to extrapolate from particle behavior to the behavior of the entire system. This is provably intractable. Think of power as a collective property, like pressure or temperature. They are very important, very useful properties, but they are completely meaningless if you want to discuss the behavior of a single molecule. Complex systems are characterized by their quantitative intractability. Our math is simply too weak, so we concentrate on areas where it is meaningful, rather than try to build a universal theory. > I believe that government intervention should ... That's politics, and is really not my thing. But even if you are interested in social science solely from the political perspective (like an engineer who's interested in science just so they can build what they always wanted to), I think you should separate the more descriptive elements (the science) from the prescriptive ones (technology), as the latter do not always directly flow from the former, and also require a good dose of ethics, which is may be very personal.
- belorn 10y agoI didn't bring up the game theory example because it can be used to build a model over a single transaction (or molecule). The same model can be used to describe property owners as a group. Since the economic models are complex enough to involve more parameters than the buyer and seller, our economical understand of society know that a housing bubble isn't caused by the property owners. They might have the upper hand, have more pressure to apply, but they aren't what causing the end result of increase prices. You say that the social science concentrate on areas where it is meaningful, but much of what we have discussed is focused on the end result. Do the property owners have, in the average, the upper hand in negotiations and do they get their way most of the time. Its an odd place to stop asking further question and not ask the question that really matter, which is what model can predict the price tomorrow. The big benefit of such model is that such theories can be tested, and later used in prescribing ways to influence the outcome.
- pron 10y agoI don't think anyone wants to "stop asking" but mathematical models of such complex systems are extremely difficult. We haven't even been able to come up with a decent mathematical model of the brain (and no, neural networks is not it), and the brain is likely a much simpler system than human society. But even if we had a good explanatory mathematical model, it could not be used to predict anything because of a technical reason, although one that seems to be -- as far as we know -- limited by theoretical constraints: our mathematical techniques simply do not allow us to predict the behaviors of systems with so many variables and so many interactions. Even numerical simulations (the kind used in weather forecasting) would diverge very quickly. In fact, measurement alone would likely take more time than the validity duration of the prediction. The problem is not unique to the social sciences. Even if biologists could understand the evolutionary mechanism in its entirety, it seems like prediction is beyond our means. All we can do is work back from results to causes, and figure out which evolutionary pressures were more powerful. Computer science is limited by similar constraints: we can explain how a bug came to be, but working forward in time and preventing all bugs requires a computational effort that is probably out of our reach. So the social sciences -- except for very special cases in psychology, where the number of variables is kept artificially low -- is content, like biology and computer science, to provide historical explanations only.