8 ms·
I know perfectly well that a fear of flying is often an irrational, though very real, fear for many people. But it's exactly the irrational nature of it that bo
by nkrisc 10y ago
I know perfectly well that a fear of flying is often an irrational, though very real, fear for many people. But it's exactly the irrational nature of it that boggles my mind: they should be terrified of driving, but they aren't.
I'm way more comfortable flying than driving.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoIt's weird how the brain works. I know very well that airliners are safe, and I'm aware just how much work goes every day to ensure they stay safe. And yet, every time I'm flying, I have this uncontrollable thought, "maybe this is the day we all crash and die". I always get a little anxious during takeoff and landing, I listen to all the noises and worry about them. "This doesn't make sense, the plane didn't usually make that sound". "Oh shit, the lights blinked, wiring must be damaged." Stuff like that. It usually takes me few minutes after liftoff to get those thoughts out of my head.
- existencebox 10y agoAt least for me there's a feeling of autonomy. If a plane crashes, there's very little that I as a non-superman can do to stop that from happening (with me inside it.) While driving, I can trust my own reflexes, awareness, and decision making to put myself in better or worse situations. Now this may still absolutely be a false perception, but this is where the feeling is rooted for me (from lengthy introspection on similar situations when I used to do trick-skiing and never really questioned my safety, but would be very hesitant to e.g. skydive). To some degree I think it's potentially also "failure magnitudes." Having been in a handful of very minimal car crashes, that calibrates my "something goes bad" prior to a not very impactful bar; whereas if something goes wrong on a plane, it can go VERY VERY wrong. Again, this is likely a false perception due to observations of outlier events in both cases and sparsity of signal, I'm just trying to question the origin of my feelings.
- mortenjorck 10y agoThere's this thing that will happen to me when I doze off as a passenger in a car: When I wake up, there's often a split second of panic between the visceral understanding that I'm in a moving vehicle and the slightly delayed recollection that I'm not the one responsible for driving it. Somehow, this turned into a problem for me when flying (even though I'm not a pilot). I wake up, I instantly know I'm moving at 500 miles per hour through the air, then I have a singular panic of being in a vehicle not under my control. This has only happened once – I haven't slept on a plane since.
- ChrisClark 10y agoSpeaking of irrational, when flying I think, "What if this is the day I discover my superpower to walk through objects and fall to the earth." I think that's about as irrational as I can get for a fear.
- bdamm 10y agoCurious phobia! Do you imagine yourself disintegrating on the surface of the earth or do you continue to fall through it?
- ChrisClark 10y agoHah yeah. I have no idea why I think of that in planes. I assume it would even be worse on ground level, fall into the bedrock and never come back up. It must be something from my childhood and stories or TV shows, and just stuck with me. I know I had recurring dreams when I was young, a futuristic belt that let me jump through walls, but detected and kept me on the floor without falling through.
- tunesmith 10y agoI tried to find the stats on this and haven't found the right ones yet. There are odds of dying in a lifetime, which is flawed because people drive more than they fly. There's also deaths per mile, which isn't right because planes go faster than cars. It seems that what people care about is what is the probability of dying in a time period of engaging in the activity? Are there stats for driver-deaths-per-time-spent-driving? It'd also be interesting if it could be broken down to driver-deaths that 100% clearly weren't the driver's fault. I wonder how that compares to deaths-per-time-flying (via a major carrier). Or probability of death. Best I could find is the micromort wikipedia page [1] - apparently to spend one micromort, you can drive 230 miles, fly 1000 miles, or train 6000 miles. Looked at that way, you're burning micromorts at a faster hourly rate on the plane, so according to that it's riskier if you squint your eyes just so. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Micromort https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Micromort
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Nition 10y agoHmm. If I'm reading that page right myself, then if you travel 1000 miles in a car there's ~4.3 times as much risk of death than if you travelled in a plane instead. So if a plane travels at least 4.3 times as FAST as a car on average, then your risk over time in a plane could be higher. I think your post makes a good point in general. Way too often, people compare statistics that don't consider major factors like how often people drive vs. fly.
- deelowe 10y agoCouldn't you just divide the deaths per mile by the typical speed of an airplane or car to normalize the data?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- rtpg 10y agoThat's probably a good first approximation, genuinely wonder about how accurate it gets. How many people die in LA gridlock? If your driving experience is "hours moving at 5mph", and your flying is "lots of shaking", easy to get scared of one. As someone who has developed a fear of flying (I still fly because I'm not taking a boat but...), one small thing that scares me is looking at plane wings in flight. A lot of bending, and a lot of parts that look old. On one flight I could see a piece of rubber stuck on the rudder , that seemed to slowly get more worn out as the rudder moved up and down. I'm sure it was by design, but at the time, I was legitimately scared. EDIT: it was a flap, not a rudder
- jraines 10y agoNervous flyer here. I tell myself this on a loop while flying and my lizard brain just does not care. Weirdly, I've flown hundreds of times and this didn't start until I was near 30. I think one aspect is not the fear of death, but the fear of being in a situation of knowing death is certain for minutes as you fall out of the sky. (Which is a situation I also know is a small fraction of the already tiny chance of dying in an airplane).
- NullCharacter 10y agoCompletely agree with you. I fly tons for work, and was just fine until I got into my mid-late twenties when I started to have horrible anxiety. And like you, I don't necessarily fear death, but I definitely don't want to see death coming. More than anything, I fear helplessness.
- gist 10y agoWhen I was a teen (long time ago) I remember telling my dad that I thought it would be great to take a flight with many stops because that way we got to takeoff and land multiple times! What fun! A bit later of course it became exactly the opposite and not just for time travel reasons, price or schedule.
- henree 10y agoI think that is pretty common and has to do with that dying isn't concrete enough for our brains. Telling people to drive slower so they don't die usually is less efficient than making them consider spending months in a hospital bed and never properly walk again etc. That said, that fear is largely irrational too since essentially no "helpless scenario" won't first have developed into an emergency. So you don't have to fear being helpless before there is an actual emergency. But you don't really have to fear emergencies either, since the far majority of emergencies (or even crashes) end well.
- bbarn 10y agoDitto. Was traveling for a living, and didn't care at all about it for years, then I got worse and worse, and had to change careers. I think part of it was the increase in stress overall after 9/11 in travelling, but maybe another part of it is doing it enough times, having enough unpleasant experiences that it's added up to me just hating everything that can happen on a typical flight. Also, dropping 10-20 feet and seeing/feeling the frame of the aircraft flexing about is just plain unsettling.
- drcode 10y agoI'm sorry, but if I'm in a tin can 30,000 feet in the air, defying gravity, I'm going to freak out at the smallest bit of turbulence, whether it's rational or not.
- quonn 10y agoMoving at 100 mph in a car does not seem exactly natural either.
- drcode 10y agoMy lizard brain disagrees with you.
- ceejayoz 10y agoA "lizard brain" (besides being a hypothesis largely dismissed by neuroscientists) seems unlikely to have any reference point or other handling for "I'm sitting in a tube 30,000 feet up at 700mph". Similar to how we're basically incapable of thinking about numbers like a billion dollars effectively.
- bdamm 10y agoInterestingly there is a great deal of work that weather services, air traffic control, and pilots do to avoid turbulence for this exact reason.
- mattnewton 10y agoI think people fear the absence of control, and the absence of understanding how flight works; even though there is a lot that can happen to you driving, you or a person you trust is usually the pilot operating a vehicle who's physics you are familiar with.
- niftich 10y agoAs another commenter said, for me it's about my personal lack of control over the outcome -- that you're completely at the whim of others (the pilots, the maintenance crew, air traffic control, etc.), which compares unfavorably with the illusion of control one has with driving. Traffic fatalities do occur to people who were not 'at-fault', and despite there being lots of good statistics on driving accidents [1][2], I can't any good ones on the ratio of serious injury or death for non-"at-fault" drivers vs. at-fault ones. Meanwhile, it would be illuminating to interview people who never drive themselves -- rather, they are always passengers -- whether they feel safer being driven, vs. flying, and the like. [1] https://crashstats.nhtsa.dot.gov/#/ https://crashstats.nhtsa.dot.gov/#/ [2] http://www.iii.org/issue-update/auto-crashes http://www.iii.org/issue-update/auto-crashes
- ceejayoz 10y agoWhile I get that, it's a little odd to have that "illusion of control" in a situation where a legally blind 90 year old with mild dementia might well be barreling down the wrong way of the highway towards you.
- jdminhbg 10y agoOthers downthread have mentioned it, but you still have an element of control in that situation. I've seen someone driving down the wrong side of the highway, and I pulled my car over and didn't get hit. Even if the % of control you personally have is small, as long as it's > 0%, you feel like you're in control of the situation. In a plane, it's 0%.
- lossolo 10y agoIt's about feeling that you are in control. You do not have control when you are flying because you are not a pilot. You are giving control over your safety and life to other people. When you drive a car you have a feeling that everything is under your control (which is not true most of the time).
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- drewrv 10y agoPeople know they're statistically safe when they go to a scary movie or a haunted house too. Fear is a primal emotion, not weighed to meaningful statistics. Airline passengers are trapped in a cramped, shaking metal tube 30,000 feet in the air. I'm surprised fear of flying isn't more common.
- cmurf 10y agoYes. It's completely rational for people to be scared out of their wits in an airplane, or higher than say twice the distance of a tree. No primate is in either situation, it's just not natural. What's different is the ability for many people to distract themselves, they have a more effective coping mechanism. There really isn't much distraction on an airplane for people who either do not read magazines/books, or watch tons of TV and movies. That's pretty much the only distraction an airplane has to offer.
- gist 10y ago> they should be terrified of driving, but they aren't Driving you can control for everything pretty much but the 'other guy'. When flying you are depending on multiple 'other guys or gals' all doing their job correctly, not making mistakes in multiple areas where there is no way for you to verify. So the unknown factor is considerably higher, regardless of statistics. With driving if the weather is bad you can typically drive later/earlier a different day. With flying that is not the case. You are locked in financially to perhaps taking a bigger chance than you might if you could just work around the weather (in two cities).
- rodgerd 10y ago> Driving you can control for everything pretty much but the 'other guy'. Yes, and all the evidence says you're terrible at it.
- wtbob 10y agoI don't know about that. Nearly every adult American drives nearly every day of his life, and only about 30,000 die each year. That's still too high, of course, and I look forward to autonomous cars, but it does mean that while many of us know of folks who've been in fatal accidents the vast, vast majority of us won't.
- draw_down 10y agoYeah, I think it's because people feel in control when they drive, whereas on a plane you're just sitting there. Of course you actually don't have any control over what other drivers do, but the feeling of control is there. Also, a car accident may not kill you, but if your plane crashes, you're dead pretty much.
- mewse 10y agoI can't explain this, but on the day I'm going to fly somewhere, I'm scared about it from the moment I wake up. Maybe 'extreme anxiety' would be a better word, since I'm not actually afraid that I'll die at that exact moment; just anticipating it later on. I remain in that state during the whole trip to the airport, during check-in, while going through security screenings and sitting in the departure lounge, and while walking through that arm thing that connects to the plane, right up until the moment that I actually sit down in my seat and buckle in. And then I'm fine. Happens every single time. And I've no clue why I could be terrified of flying when I'm on the ground, but totally fine when I actually am flying.
- bearcobra 10y agoI get this too. The second I close the zipper on my suitcase I start to feel anxious until I'm in the skyway. I wonder if missing a flight would cure it