3 ms·
Very interesting, but I think most of the comments are missing the point that this isn't about the technology. It is about telling the user where they can and
by pedalpete 17y ago
Very interesting, but I think most of the comments are missing the point that this isn't about the technology.
It is about telling the user where they can and cannot go.
We wouldn't accept that in a car for any reason.
Wanna go to Yosemite, great! But that parking lot isn't paved, so you can't stop there.
You can drive by and see the rest of it from the highway though!
Oh, that highway is nice and paved, but it leads to google and some fancy voice technology they built. I'm sure as a driver you'd like to see it, but you'll just have to stick to our roads and roads that don't compete with us on any level.
- pohl 17y agoWe wouldn't accept that in a car for any reason. Really? I see these on the road all the time and I would have no trouble whatsoever finding a road they couldn't handle. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smart_(automobile) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smart_(automobile) Consumers do, in fact, willingly buy cars that limit their travels. Heck, a lot of people willingly buy cars that don't have enough oomph to take an entirely paved route over the rocky mountains.
- pedalpete 17y agoA Smart car CAN'T go on an unpaved road? 'maybe' a Smart car shouldn't go on an unpaved road, but that decision isn't made for you by the manufacturer, or anybody else. You're free to take the Smart car you purchased anywhere you want.
- pohl 17y agoI took your use of the word "can" to mean "able to". Clearly you meant it in the alternate sense of "permitted to". I see that now. If your objection rests upon such a distinction, then shouldn't we be a bit more disciplined about exactly who the restriction is being placed upon? You imply that it's a restriction against the person buying the phone, but this is not the case. They have no such restrictions placed upon them. Section 3.3.1 is in the Terms of Service for the App Store, not in a license for the phone. It is the developer who it restricts, not the owner of the device.
- sendos 17y agoI think most of the comments are missing the point that this isn't about the technology. It is about telling the user where they can and cannot go Bingo! It's like if an Italian suite maker somehow made it impossible for you to eat a hot dog while wearing the suite, because of the increased risk of getting mustard on the suite, thus ruining the experience of wearing the perfect suite. Look, I paid for the suite, I know that eating some foods will increase the probability that the suite will be soiled, and, I want to be allowed to make the decision whether or not to take that risk.
- zts 17y agoI'd say it's more like the organisers of a suit convention not allowing a hotdog vendor to operate inside. This upsets the people who understand the risks associated with eating hotdogs while wearing their suits, while protecting other suit-wearers who don't appreciate the risk of soiling. The problem with this analogy is that while any reasonable person can foresee condiment spillage, the average consumer is utterly unaware of the tradeoffs that Apple appears to be concerned about. Nor should they need to be.