4 ms·
> Really hard problems, problems that might reveal that Google is not omnipotent, where Google might not succeed, Google pulls back from. I've heard this phras
by ForHackernews 10y ago
> Really hard problems, problems that might reveal that Google is not omnipotent, where Google might not succeed, Google pulls back from.
I've heard this phrased as "Google has the good fortune to be operating in a field where being 90% right 90% of the time is more than good enough"
If the search result you want is number 3 instead of number 1, that's totally acceptable. If your ad-targeting is good but not perfect, you can still make enormous amounts of money.
There are other domains where 90%/90% is absolutely unacceptable: avionics, medical life support, rocket propulsion, etc.
- user5994461 10y ago> "Google has the good fortune to be operating in a field where being 90% right 90% of the time is more than good enough" I don't think it's an accurate view. It was good enough when they started. Now they are doing a lot better than that. The results are moved dynamically per user over hundreds of criteria. It really is not a dumb search/ad engine that anyone could replicate easy. They have evolved to be damn efficient at what they do.
- ForHackernews 10y ago> It really is not a dumb search/ad engine that anyone could replicate easy. I'm not saying it's simple or could be replicated easily. I'm saying that the marginal improvements they've made don't really matter that much to users. I mostly use DuckDuckGo these days, and its native search results are markedly inferior to Google's, but it basically doesn't matter because I still almost always get what I want on the first page of results.
- euyyn 10y agoThat doesn't sound like good fortune for Google.
- zardeh 10y agoBut it does matter to a lot of people, which I think is the thing. There will absolutely be people who are willing to sacrifice some ease-of-use in the name of additional privacy, but it seems that those people are in the minority, and that means that Google (or whomever) needs to provide 99/99 when everyone else is only 90/90, if they want to continue being market leaders.
- ForHackernews 10y ago"But it does matter to a lot of people" Does it? Imagine some alternate reality where Bing were the dominant search engine (or look at real world cases like Russia, where Yandex dominates), do you think that Google's marginally superior results would be enough to make users switch? I propose that Google reached a market-leading position early on by being pretty good when other search engines were pretty bad. Since then, they've become the "default" option, and people will keep using what they're accustomed to.