3 ms·
But downloading Signal after news like these will tag people as trying to hide something from the state.
by visarga 10y ago
But downloading Signal after news like these will tag people as trying to hide something from the state.
- antocv 10y agoNot only tag, but also get their identity and possibly use backdoors, because Signal is only on Google Play, which in order to access it requires a gazillion identifying data. Signal is a joke if your adversary is NSA and its likes. You cant run Signal unless you give up who you are, and that you are using it, and its not very difficult to analyze _when_ you receiveor send a message due to the Signal requiring google messaging system. Signal should just really rename itself to "Google Signal, no really we are not evil for certain."
- arglebarnacle 10y agoMost people only have the NSA as an adversary in the minimal sense that they're caught up in a very broad mass surveillance net. It's true that if you're a whistleblower with sensitive government information Signal is not a complete solution for you. But who cares? Almost nobody is in that situation, and people in that situation have access to other tools that actually do help. Your last sentence is extremely unfair to Signal and dramatically underrates the privacy it provides to ordinary people. It's dangerous to suggest that because it requires a phone number and lives on an app store it provides no useful protection at all, because that implies it's no better than e.g. WhatsApp when in fact it has a much better featureset.
- pdkl95 10y ago> Almost nobody is in that situation Almost everybody might be in that situation, because the NSA is not the only group that has access to the data they collect. They call it "parallel construction", where the NSA's "customers" like the DEA simply have to fill out a form[1] to get surveillance data, and promise to lie about the source in court. [1] https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20140203/11143926078/parallel-construction-revealed-how-dea-is-trained-to-launder-classified-surveillance-info.shtml https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20140203/11143926078/paral...
- antocv 10y agoLOL, its not better than WhatsApp, that is my point. In fact, its worse than cleartext SMS, when you use Signal you are a target, when you use cleartext SMS, you can still hide among the noise.
- Forbo 10y agoNot everyone's threat model is nation-state adversaries. Often times it is simple theft, coercion, snooping friends/family, etc. What messaging system would your recommend instead? Riot? Tox? Last I checked, neither were nearly as polished and feature-complete as Signal. In my use case, unless it is good enough to become a daily driver, many people won't even bother with it. What good is a messaging system that nobody else uses?
- antocv 10y agoUse what the masses are using, anonymity is being in a large enough group and not distinguished enough from the rest. Telegram, cleartext SMS, email. Normal people do not send anonymous or secure messages, but if you need and want to, then you cant just install an app and be done with it, you have to first find and install I2P which is not traceable to you (good luck, first get a degree in information security and become Linux guru), then join an I2P only IRC channel and begin messaging with your group of people about plan to watch football and drink beer, after you had the secret communication with bitmessage over I2P.
- arglebarnacle 10y agoI think it is a mistake to buy into the logic that using encryption means you have something to hide. Regardless of the framing of the article, many people likely read this and thought, "yes, it would be nice to be confident my messaging is private even from mass government surveillance." This does not mean they are drug dealers. It means that they have concluded wide-dragnet surveillance programs are worth opting out of, especially if it's very easy to do so.
- wruza 10y ago>encryption means you have something to hide It means for me, but I fail to see why it is bad. Even direct "not your business" does not prove any guilt. It is okay to hide, we don't have to be open book.
- mtgx 10y agoI think it says more about you being so willing to accept the state's logic that if you use such apps you have something to hide and you'll be automatically put on lists, than it says about the people using it. That's exactly how the government wants people to think about this stuff, and it just wants you to give in to plaintext mass surveillance. Why make it so easy for them?