3 ms·
If find the discussions around this area interesting. In many ways this is exactly how science operates, people come up with new things, either through observat
by ChuckMcM 10y ago
If find the discussions around this area interesting. In many ways this is exactly how science operates, people come up with new things, either through observation or theory, they think about them and write about them and everyone else gets to decide if they are right or wrong. And there is never all right, or all wrong, but really just more questions. So if A is true does that mean B is true? Can we test to see if B is true? How about C, D, or E? All lead to investigation which leads to experiments which leads to discussion and arguments and finally to something useful.
Pons and Fleischman got a raw deal, it was perfectly reasonable for people to say "I don't believe you did your experiments correctly" or "I don't agree with the interpretation of the data you received." But it was wrong to call them fraudsters. It was also wrong to attach a stigma to people who were investigating things that were not supposed to be possible as cranks or gullible.
And yet a number of scientists of various levels of skill have continued and very slowly over time there have been experiments that could be repeated that exhibited behaviors that are not easily explained by the existing rules (which mostly are "no nuclear events at these temperatures and pressures.") As the article points out the micrographs of the metal surfaces are of particular interest because even if you don't believe in these events being nuclear, it is equally challenging to come up with a chemical explanation for the features found on the electrodes. Physical scarring that does not look like either plating or erosion, and chemical constituents which are not known to have any sort of exothermic reactivity.
So there is something there, not sure what it is and current theories don't explain it well or at all. That should be a source of excitement for scientists right? Doesn't seem so, instead you attacks on the people just trying to run the experiments!
When I see people unable to embrace a result for what seems like it would put them in the position of having been wrong earlier, I wonder "What drew this person into science in the first place?"
- dhimes 10y agoPons and Fleischman got a raw deal Maybe in the end, but they kind of brought it on themselves. They were excoriated for going to the press before peer review. That's something that you just didn't do. Then when nobody else could get their results they were in a bad place. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13130002 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13130002