4 ms·
And having a separate non-email username is an antipattern
by nailer 10y ago
And having a separate non-email username is an antipattern
- minitech 10y agoHow so? For a website like Twitter, for example, it’s convenient to be able to: - Tell people how to get to your profile in person (and remember how to get to someone’s profile without needing a link) - Mention people by name - Keep your e-mail address private You might also want to associate the same e-mail address with multiple profiles. This seems like an overgeneralization.
- nailer 10y agoWhile outside publishing platforms those needs are rare (and that's why I consider it an antipattern) I agree with you in terms of a publishing platform.
- cesarb 10y agoHaving a separate non-email username allows the user to change his email, for instance when he changes his ISP (many people still use ISP-provided email), or if his current email provides ceases providing service.
- kalleboo 10y agoWhy couldn't you change your email when it's your username?
- nommm-nommm 10y agoFinancial institutions do this. I guess its part of layered security. It's annoying but I can see why they do it, I wouldn't consider it an anti-pattern.
- nailer 10y agoI could change the email if I know the username and password. I could change the username if I have access to the email and password. If it adds no benefit then it should be removed.
- nommm-nommm 10y ago>I could change the username if I have access to the email and password. No you can't. Lets say I download a database leak of email/password combos from a popular service. I can't go onto bankofamerica.com or whatever and start iterating through that leak for password reuse, I don't know the username for a given email account. Usually password reset goes something like this: If I click on "forgot password" it asks for username and email address to email me a password reset link. If I click on "forgot username" it asks for email address and other information a financial institution would know, like SSN, account number, credit card number, CVV code. You can't do anything with just email and password. You can't even do anything with access to that email address and password. I just reset my password with Wells Fargo last night and it even gave me security challenge questions from my credit report to change my password (questions like what car did you own, what's the payment amount for your mortgage, what address are you associated with, where does $(relative) live?).