5 ms·
You don't often go from "nothing" to "proof it works" in a single iteration of a new technology.
by onion2k 10y ago
You don't often go from "nothing" to "proof it works" in a single iteration of a new technology.
- greglindahl 10y agoIndeed, if you look at the history of science, even modern examples such as the discovery of H. Pylori, it's a messy process. However, don't be confused by survivor bias: almost all extraordinary results turn out to be experimental error.
- snowwrestler 10y agoFine, but let's also recognize that this is not yet one of them. It might be an error, in fact it almost certainly will be. But it is not yet certainly an error. Stand back: science still in progress!
- Retric 10y agoBut you should not be trying to prove it works. You should be trying to disprove it, until no other reasonable explanation is left. The most obvious example is to use normal water instead of heavy water and see if you get similar results.