4 ms·
I've been playing Nethack and other roguelikes for well over 20 years. Nethack has to be the one game out of all the games that I've played that I played the l
by pmoriarty 10y ago
I've been playing Nethack and other roguelikes for well over 20 years. Nethack has to be the one game out of all the games that I've played that I played the longest. As you can probably tell, I love Nethack.
DCSS is the game that has made me more or less abandon Nethack to play it instead. It improves on Nethack in so many ways: from the super useful auto-explore, to the beautiful and innovative use of colors, lots and lots of really bizzare and unique gods, beautiful and interesting thematic levels, a Lua scripting interface, and much, much more. I'm seriously impressed with how much the DCSS developers have achieved, and how quickly they've achieved it.
It's also telling that Nethack has traditionally had a glacial development cycle, while DCSS development is super active. There are tons of new features, races, levels, and gods in nearly every release, and new releases come out all the time.
That said, there are still other things that Nethack does best. The crazy number of things that you can do with items and bodies in Nethack seems deeper than DCSS, as are some of the relationships with one's god in Nethack, and the use of pets (such as training them to steal from shops). Someone told me that a DCSS deverloper motto is "when it doubt, don't do it like Nethack", which is a pity, because they could learn from Nethack and take some of the things it does best and improve on them, instead of stubbornly refusing to be like Nethack. That said, none of this is going to stop me from playing DCSS, which is now by far my favorite rougelike of all.
I strongly recommend anyone who has even the remotest interest in rogulikes give DCSS a try, if you've somehow missed the boat and haven't already.
Also, playing in ASCII is the one true way to play. ;) You can ssh or telnet in to a server to play, if you want to play online (or watch others play).[1] Or you can download and compile the game itself to play locally on your own machine.[2]
Finally, if you ever need help, check out ##crawl on freenode.[3]
[1] - https://crawl.develz.org/wordpress/howto https://crawl.develz.org/wordpress/howto
[2] - https://crawl.develz.org/wordpress/ https://crawl.develz.org/wordpress/
[3] - https://freenode.net/ https://freenode.net/
- chongli 10y agoI've seen a lot of these threads and without fail the comparison between DCSS and NetHack comes up. I can't remember the last time somebody said they loved NetHack in one of these threads, so kudos to you! Personally, I am one of the rare birds that loves NetHack and just can't stand DCSS. NetHack feels far closer to a proper role-playing game with an actual dungeon master who will listen to your crazy ideas and give you back a result that actually makes sense. DCSS, on the other hand, feels more like an arcade beat-em-up style game to me. I guess it doesn't help that my favourite combo (fulsome distillation and evaporate) was removed from the game a few years ago. Beyond that, I find DCSS really dry. Most of the time you're just mashing the auto-explore key and then bumping into a few enemies or repeatedly casting your best spell at them. For the style of game it is (beat-em-up Roguelike with zero role-playing) I'd much rather play TOME[0], a game that has far more intricate and involved character classes. [0] http://te4.org/ http://te4.org/
- bhaak 10y ago> [...] Someone told me that a DCSS deverloper motto is "when it doubt, don't do it like Nethack", which is a pity, because they could learn from Nethack and take some of the things it does best and improve on them, instead of stubbornly refusing to be like Nethack. [...] Many of the DCSS devs are former NetHack players, at least one is a former NetHack fork developer, so they know NetHack well. Don't think that they dismiss features just because NetHack shares them. The quote says "when in doubt" so it's just one aspect that gets taken into consideration when adding or changing the game. Although if you read the design document of DCSS, you'll see that they won't include some of the crazy things you mentioned because it goes against their vision of the game in the first place (I disagree with the god relationship though, for some classes it's much more involved in DCSS than NetHack).