7 ms·
Hackers killed the Hollywood hacker. (Hackers as in people, not Hackers the film.) Dominic Sena, in his director's commentary for Swordfish, stated that the peo
by bitwize 10y ago
Hackers killed the Hollywood hacker. (Hackers as in people, not Hackers the film.) Dominic Sena, in his director's commentary for Swordfish, stated that the people who were likely to complain about the inaccuracy of the hacking shown in his movie were nerds who ultimately didn't matter. In this era where the internet response can make or break a film or TV show, the nerds do matter and directors go the extra mile to please them. This started before Mr. Robot. Think Tron: Legacy.
- macspoofing 10y agoIt's not even a nerd thing. I found that I enjoyed technical jargon even when I didn't understand the meaning behind all the words. I doubt every viewer understands everything Big Bang Theory physicists say, but it's still fun! It does seem to enhance the experience plus it has the side benefit of buying good will from the experts in the relevant field.
- smnplk 10y agoI never understood what people find funny in Big bang theory show. Can you still laugh at the jokes if there is no laugh track https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AY0Zkthn8Og https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AY0Zkthn8Og ? :) I like IT crowd much better.
- beedogs 10y agoAgreed. BBT is a terrible show with mostly cringe-worthy humour.
- veridies 10y agoFirst of all, while BBT may sweeten the track, it is still filmed in front of an audience; people really do laugh at the jokes. It doesn't work at all in part because the actors pause to let the laughter subside, and if you watch without that, it just feels bizarre. Second of all, the show's humor isn't entirely verbal. The overbroad stereotypes and exaggerated reactions are part of a joke, and a lot of that requires a familiarity with (and appreciation of) both the specific characters and the archetypes they're playing on. Of course some people just won't find the show funny, and that's fine. But a lot of very experienced, talented people put a lot of work into that show; it would be unfortunate to dismiss it entirely. (And for the record, I personally don't find the show funny in the least bit.)
- forgottenpass 10y agoFirst of all, while BBT may sweeten the track, it is still filmed in front of an audience; people really do laugh at the jokes. I never really understood the idea that this is meaningfully different from a canned laughter track. A live audience applauding because the applause light goes on isn't any more authentic than a editor mixing it in. It's just easier to make the end product sound like it flows realistically. And while there may not be a "laughter" light, the audience knows that they're expected to laugh at the punchlines. Just like they know to "ooh" and "aww" at all the right moments too. In fact the crowd warm-up often tells them to make sure they laugh and laugh loud enough for the microphones to pick it up. -- In either case, the reason people bounce off of laughter in the mix is because the jokes don't land. It's the fact people would find it funny that people complaining about the "laugh track" perceive as artificial. Not because the audio is stilted enough that someone can recognize it as edited in after the fact. Getting pedantic about the colloquial use of "laugh track" or "canned" is generally irrelevant.
- na85 10y agoI've never even cracked a smile at BBT. It's easily the worst show on television.
- racl101 10y agoI think this, what you have stated, is the appeal of that scene in the Social Network where Mark Zuckerberg is building Facesmash: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VSKoVsHs_Ko https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VSKoVsHs_Ko Most people probably don't understand what Emacs, Apache configuration or "wget magic" is but they don't have to. Sorkin's screenplay makes, what might otherwise be a boring evening to a external observer, seem really exciting while communicating the high level ideas. In other words: people who saw the movie partook in the excitement of watching a programmer build something cool, fairly quickly, that elicited strong feedback and reaction, which is rewarding to any programmer and they did not have to get bogged down in the details. As well, this scene also doesn't embellish in the details of hacking with absurd looking command lines nor GUIs like "Hackers" (the movie) does and, therefore, does not elicit an obligatory 'eyeroll' from the programmer/hacker community.
- rileymat2 10y agoIt was so far off, that I actually loved the hacking scene in Swordfish.
- talmand 10y agoThe excitement, the random key pounding, the yelling at the screen, the celebration... It's a typical work day for me.
- darkarmani 10y ago> This started before Mr. Robot. Think Tron: Legacy. Think The Matrix: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0PxTAn4g20U https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0PxTAn4g20U Using nmap to find a vulnerable ssh server for the SSH CRC32 attack.
- ortuna 10y agoYou might enjoy https://nmap.org/movies/ https://nmap.org/movies/
- craigyk 10y agoNo, humans as batteries was a stupid plot device. Still a neat movie, but instantly disqualified as a classic because of that unforced error.
- flashman 10y agoPass it off as Morpheus not understanding the machines' true purposes. He believes it, but we don't have proof. Perhaps the machines use human brains as cloud infrastructure, for storage and highly parallel processing. (I also like Eliezer Yudkowsky's theory that the Laws of Thermodynamics are an in-simulation creation by the machines, and humans-as-batteries works according to the laws of the real universe.)
- anigbrowl 10y agoDirectors and writers (who come up with the actual story 99% of the time) have always gone the extra mile to please a favored demographic (or occasionally offend a disfavored one). Think aristocrats in any Shakespeare play. I'm tempted to reach back even farther, but classical Greek drama was generally completely rooted in divine miracles because that was how most people thought the world actually worked back then, and you could get in trouble for saying otherwise, as Socrates discovered. However, in Plato's Dialogues Socrates puts in a lot of time displaying or eliciting military knowledge from his interlocutors, since they were the elite of Athenian society and Plato's target audience for his ideas on statecraft.
- TheSpiceIsLife 10y agothat was how most people thought the world actually worked back then How can we know this? Who is "most people"? If Shakespeare wrote to please the aristocracy, might it be possible that the surviving Greek writing was written to please some other set of elites / religious authority / etc. Edited to add: I imagine the average working class person, or peasant, what have you, might have privately said or thought "Miracles, what a load of dingo's kidneys", much like we do today about whatever we don't believe.
- anigbrowl 10y agoWe can know this through the study of history, and the relative absence of non-divine explanations for mysterious phenomena from the same period. Absent the germ theory of disease, for example, people proffered various fantastical explanations for patient's illnesses, from divine punishment to demonic interference. The incompleteness of our knowledge is not a good reason to avoid forming hypotheses. I imagine the average working class person, or peasant, what have you, might have privately said or thought "Miracles, what a load of dingo's kidneys" That's because you have a host of other ideas to draw on. What if you didn't have all that scientific knowledge and people in your village started dying mysteriously? Look at how people are in undeveloped places, if they're not educated they tend to blame evil spirits or say that someone caused a curse to fall on the village and suchlike.