6 ms·
I agree that it's an overused trope, but don't think it's fair to say that schizophrenia keeps people from accomplishing impressive things (eg TempleOS)
by Rebelgecko 10y ago
I agree that it's an overused trope, but don't think it's fair to say that schizophrenia keeps people from accomplishing impressive things (eg TempleOS)
- ubercore 10y agoTempleOS may be impressive, but it's not especially effective
- cmurf 10y agoIt's an effective example of the possible benefit having a double major in psych and computer science. However, that is impressive psychopathology. I had no idea.
- throwanem 10y agoIt's impressive, to be sure. Is it useful?
- aoeu345 10y agoIt is a tool to learn about how your computer really works by providing an extremely simple operating system. It's so simple you can draw circles on the screen with one line at the command prompt. It is very dumb to argue it has no usefulness because it does not work with modern dev tools or environments
- na85 10y agoCorrection: it is a tool to learn how modern processors emulate x86. Learning C or asm gives you no insight into what the microcode under the hood is doing.
- throwanem 10y agoAnd I'm quite certain there are better tools than TempleOS to learn how an x86 processor works.
- enraged_camel 10y agoReally? Such as?
- ambicapter 10y agoProbably a textbook.
- aoeu345 10y agoPerhaps then one ought to use a textbook and TempleOS side-by-side to learn x86.
- yarou 10y agoIt's coding for its own sake, much like how art isn't useful in the traditional sense.
- throwanem 10y agoSure. But usefulness is the criterion under discussion here.
- usefulissubj33 10y agoUsefulness is subjective. Some people learn well through certain methods than others. Some people stick with the first thing that they find and make it work for their needs. Never discovering the "better tools". Richard Feynman, often regarded as one of the best teachers of physics to have ever lived, when asked how to teach, said he didn't know. He just tried to bring as many views to the table as possible. Some people learn from simple high-level descriptions, others need more details to build up to high-level understanding. Pretty sure you're just being contrarian to be contrarian. Because it seems you're suggesting your way and the things you find the most value in are the only way. Which is a nonsense counter-argument to the question "Why does this thing exist." Your criterion feels more like "I don't get why it exists. Thus it's useless." Self-aggrandizing nonsense.
- throwanem 10y agoIt's not my criterion; this discussion originated in a comment (not mine) claiming roughly that the products of mental illness are of no use to anyone. And I know full well why TempleOS exists: God told Terry Davis to build it. While that clearly means a lot to Mr. Davis, I am not sure how much validity you mean it to have to anyone else. As it happens, I tend to agree that utility is where you find it. But that's not at all the same as saying that TempleOS is a good teaching tool. Perhaps it is. But thus far I see nothing save repeated assertion to support that claim, and it would be nice to see a bit more by way of substantiation. For example, someone claimed that, because you can draw circles at the command line with TempleOS, it is simple. But I can do that too, with a terminal and a gnuplot build that include sixel graphics support. (I did it the other day for grins.) Does that mean my setup is simple? Obviously not. Why does it mean that TempleOS is? What does the existence of the capability say about TempleOS's suitability for teaching? Does it say anything? If it does, no one has seen fit to explain how. The same goes for the fact that TempleOS is written in C and assembly. Lots of things are written in C and assembly. Are they all good teaching tools? (Also: A throwaway, for this? Why?)
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- sedachv 10y agoPeople like Terry Davis and Yayoi Kusama are outliers. Can you name any other schizophrenics that have accomplished impressive things? The only reason they are able to keep working is a lot of support from others over the years to help them overcome the negative effects of their mental illness - Davis' family made sure he received hospital treatment and now he lives on Social Security Disability; Kusama has been living full-time in a mental hospital for the last several decades.
- majormajor 10y agoWriting compelling dramatic fiction about people who aren't outliers is hard, and that's something far more widespread than just Mr. Robot and the "exceptional genius" hacker idea.
- vanderZwan 10y ago> People like Terry Davis and Yayoi Kusama are outliers. And is it so strange for a lead character in a movie or TV series to represent an outlier?
- arijo 10y agoWhat exactly are you trying to achieve with your argument? Do you think the kind of stigma you're contributing to persist will encourage any productive person with a serious mental illness to be open about their work?
- talmand 10y agoCan we not consider that Mr. Robot is an outlier in the show's world?
- recursive 10y agoStories about typical people doing typical things are not very compelling.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- RUG3Y 10y agoIn the show, Elliot is actually not all that functional. He's debilitated - he can't remember where he's been or what he's done, he's socially awkward and destroys his relationships, and he gets in a lot of bad situations as a result. He's also a drug addict. Maybe the picture of his life isn't all that unbelievable.
- saycheese 10y agoReview of TempleOS, its developer and their history with HN are covered: http://www.codersnotes.com/notes/a-constructive-look-at-templeos/ http://www.codersnotes.com/notes/a-constructive-look-at-temp...