3 ms·

"Typing isn't a magic bullet, ..., but it sure makes development easier and your apps more stable." That right there is the whole essence of typed programming

by eklavya 10y ago

"Typing isn't a magic bullet, ..., but it sure makes development easier and your apps more stable." That right there is the whole essence of typed programming :)

stcredzero 10y ago
Going one level deeper, the underlying truism is that computers make better bean counters than people, even programmers. Type systems are good insofar as they free up cognitive resources of the programmer. Conversely, type systems are bad when they make programmers burn attention resources without enough return. (This is a difficult thing for people to evaluate, because sometimes the "return" from a type system can pay off many years later.) Again, it all comes down to cost-benefit. A new, modern 21st century language should be designed with the above in mind. The type system should make the resulting apps more stable, stay out of the way of coders reading code and writing new code, yet enable powerful tooling that doesn't need a heavyweight background process running a O(n^4) algorithm to collate meta-level information to enable all the IDE features. (Ideally, the tooling should be able to parse everything it needs to parse at some small multiple of the time it takes to read the source files off the drive.) Again, it's all about cost-benefit! "Elegance" or popularity with tech hipsters be damned, what's the cost, and what does it get you? (The nickel-and-dime costs of waiting around for lugubrious and unresponsive tools not only add up, they operate with some huge multiplier effect.)
- sjwright 10y ago
  In my opinion, the critical aspect of typed code is the ability to declare a variable as either a number, string or binary. Let me declare this up front, let the compiler enforce it, and my mind is freed from semi-paranoid concerns about edge cases and spurious inputs. But sometimes I don't care exactly what sort of number is used. This is where many type systems go overboard, by forcing me pick a 64 bit unsigned integer or whatever.

by eklavya 10y ago

"Typing isn't a magic bullet, ..., but it sure makes development easier and your apps more stable." That right there is the whole essence of typed programming :)

stcredzero 10y ago

Going one level deeper, the underlying truism is that computers make better bean counters than people, even programmers. Type systems are good insofar as they free up cognitive resources of the programmer. Conversely, type systems are bad when they make programmers burn attention resources without enough return. (This is a difficult thing for people to evaluate, because sometimes the "return" from a type system can pay off many years later.) Again, it all comes down to cost-benefit. A new, modern 21st century language should be designed with the above in mind. The type system should make the resulting apps more stable, stay out of the way of coders reading code and writing new code, yet enable powerful tooling that doesn't need a heavyweight background process running a O(n^4) algorithm to collate meta-level information to enable all the IDE features. (Ideally, the tooling should be able to parse everything it needs to parse at some small multiple of the time it takes to read the source files off the drive.) Again, it's all about cost-benefit! "Elegance" or popularity with tech hipsters be damned, what's the cost, and what does it get you? (The nickel-and-dime costs of waiting around for lugubrious and unresponsive tools not only add up, they operate with some huge multiplier effect.)

sjwright 10y ago
In my opinion, the critical aspect of typed code is the ability to declare a variable as either a number, string or binary. Let me declare this up front, let the compiler enforce it, and my mind is freed from semi-paranoid concerns about edge cases and spurious inputs. But sometimes I don't care exactly what sort of number is used. This is where many type systems go overboard, by forcing me pick a 64 bit unsigned integer or whatever.