8 ms·
But it's already like that. They removed the API that allowed RES to show you individual up/down votes per-post. They've banned tons of subs for varying levels
by djsumdog 10y ago
But it's already like that. They removed the API that allowed RES to show you individual up/down votes per-post. They've banned tons of subs for varying levels of controversy. They removed their warranty canary. Their CEO was caught changing comments and they weren't asked to resign; got away with just an apology?
I realize that Voat is a cesspool, but anonymity -- real anonymity -- tends to let you see peoples' real dark opinions (hence all the chans .. and why Google requires real profiles for YouTube comments now).
I think Reddit filters a lot more than people realize; more than just the banned subreddits and edited comments. It's been a filter bubble for quite some time.
In anycase, I've given up on Reddit .. and Voat. I guess my big addiction now is Hackernews. :-P
- komali2 10y agoI like Hackernews because I actually learn things here and have genuinely interesting conversations with relatively polite people, but we only seem to talk about tech stuff. Cryptography, web dev, programming, etc. Nobody here wants to talk about like, motorcycles or raising pet rats or other things I'm interested in outside of technology, so it can't replace reddit for me.
- themoat 10y agoYeah that's kind of where I'm at with Reddit as well. It's not a place where I can browse anymore. I just can't bring myself to wade through /r/all, but there are certain subreddits where they just really have the community size that can't be found outside reddit.
- HCIdivision17 10y agoAnd not even all tech! I've actually started spending more time on Reddit because it's more interesting in general. When a post percolates up here about motorcycles or manufacturing or some cool analytics on an obscure topic, I have a great time. But they're not common, and there's always some StackOverflow-style "this doesn't belong on HackerNews". (But they also seem to pull people out of the woodwork like gangbusters - HN loves the occasional off-topic interesting post! But not constantly :) Which is fine, I guess. That's why we have things like Reddit! Perhaps it's a variant of the Unix Way: have sites that provide a specific style of service, either in content management or filtering or whatnot. And appreciate them for that!
- dang 10y agoYou two should post such stories here, then. They're explicitly on topic: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- HCIdivision17 10y agoTo be sure, and you've done a masterful job encouraging it! I usually see you there to prop up the cool stuff, and I certainly appreciate it. And in full fairness, when I made that comment, a whole bunch of stories were non-tech related, but interesting, so I probably should retract my comment =/. (One was about bread!)
- coreyp_1 10y agoI'm afraid that our research group was the reason that Reddit removed access to the vote count. Not that it has stopped us from doing research on reddit... We submitted another paper a week or so ago, and will be releasing or dataset upon publication.
- minimaxir 10y agoThat's unlikely. For clarification, only the breakdown of up/downs was hidden, not the overall score, and it was hidden because when people saw posts with tons of downvotes, it invited more downvotes.
- coreyp_1 10y agoAlexis Ohanian visits Notre Dame, & specifically meets with my advisor. We show them what we are working on in regards to analyzing Reddit (probably not the wisest thing to show them a work in progress, before all the data is collected). They're not thrilled about it. A few weeks later, a crucial part of the information is gone. You tell me.
- minimaxir 10y agoThe change happened in 2014 (http://www.reddit.com/r/announcements/comments/28hjga/reddit_changes_individual_updown_vote_counts_no/ http://www.reddit.com/r/announcements/comments/28hjga/reddit...), when Ohanian had less of an affiliation with Reddit.
- coreyp_1 10y agoThat's also when he came to Notre Dame.
- pmarreck 10y agoWhat does your research entail? Sounds tantalizing
- 10y ago
- ovulator 10y agoIn regards to the warrant canary, well, that is kind of how that works.
- erikpukinskis 10y ago> anonymity -- real anonymity -- tends to let you see peoples' real dark opinions No, it lets you see a narrow slice of people's real, dark opinions. There are a whole host of opinions you'll never see on Voat because the user base is antagonistic to the basic ideas which underpin them, so there's no point in trying to express them on that platform. For example, the notion that men are psychologically torturing women just by enacting common male body movement patterns in the workplace would never see the light of day on Voat. That's dark. It's my real opinion. There's no such thing as a "bastion of free speech". One person's safe space is another person's hell of antagonism.
- amitdeshwar 10y agoCan you elaborate on what you mean by "men are psychologically torturing women just by enacting common male body movement patterns in the workplace" ?
- zbuttram 10y agoYeah, I'm also interested. That statement is like those local news promos people like to make fun of, "it's killing millions of Americans and you could be eating it for dinner, find out on tonight's news at 10!"
- kbenson 10y agoI'm wondering too. The only thing that comes immediately to mind is adjusting your pants in the crotch area, which, well, sometimes it's uncomfortable without there being any sort of excitement, and it's just a matter of comfort. Like pulling your underwear out of your but. If that's an example of what's being referred to, it's really, really unfortunate, because it's a matter of one party acting totally innocently (most of the time), and the other party being conditioned to take it in a non-innocent way. That said, I could be totally off-base.
- Humdeee 10y agoNot off base at all. Even with your off the top of your head example, I'm sure everyone reading this can think of that person they know that would get offended by a male "repositioning" himself.
- pmarreck 10y agoSerious question- Do you think there's room for a new discussion site which embraced all these lessons that other discussion sites seem to perpetually be ignoring (perhaps due to simple entrenchment)? Because I have oft floated the idea of starting just such a site. Anyway, I somehow (as an avid Reddit user) missed the news that they lost their warrant canary (probably because I unsubbed from almost all the default subs due to low signal/noise ratio): https://www.reddit.com/r/worldnews/comments/4ct1kz/reddit_deletes_surveillance_warrant_canary_in/ https://www.reddit.com/r/worldnews/comments/4ct1kz/reddit_de... But in googling it, I did notice an interesting site related to warrant canaries: https://canarywatch.org/ https://canarywatch.org/ EDIT: crap, no longer being updated: https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2016/05/canary-watch-one-year-later https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2016/05/canary-watch-one-year-...
- duiker101 10y agoI guess the problems come with the fame. As long as you are a small site, you can do pretty much whatever you want, but as you grow, you have to compromise in some way. You can bend to advertisers and lose some of freedom, or go down the chan way and get a name that reflects what you have to offer and probably have a revenue that is consistent with that. On top of that , there's the fact that the average user, simply doesn't care about all this freedoms or number of upvotes and stuff like that. They just want content and reddit right now has enough for everyone.
- jokermatt999 10y agoWhat lessons would you like to include on such a site? Off the top of my head, my favorite things about Hacker News: high level civil discourse, lack of humor (no, seriously, humor easily crowds out good discussion on other sites), excellent layout (collapsible tree comments), anonymous speech with ease to creating new accounts, light handed and responsive moderation. There's not much I don't like: narrow focus on tech rather than just general good content (but that is why it was created), no easy way to collapse a comment tree when you've scrolled partway through it, and... that's really it. What specifically would you like to differently? I'm interested in more good discussion sites.
- 10y ago
- cbr 10y ago> Google requires real profiles for YouTube comments now This was rolled back a couple years ago: https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2014/jul/16/youtube-trolls-google-real-name-commenter-policy https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2014/jul/16/youtube-t... (Disclosure: I work for Google, on unrelated things.)
- rickhanlonii 10y agoFWIW they removed the individual upvoat/downvote counts because they were essentially made up
- chetanahuja 10y ago"Google requires real profiles for YouTube comments now" And consequently, Youtube comments now solely consist of civil dialogue and scholarly critiques of videos.