3 ms·
Yes, but fuel isn't free, vehicles are not free (shrinkage isn't free). Margins on these goods is very poor (1% [1] makes or breaks an outfit). Now, let's say
by mc32 10y ago
Yes, but fuel isn't free, vehicles are not free (shrinkage isn't free). Margins on these goods is very poor (1% [1] makes or breaks an outfit). Now, let's say you're right, they want to get the technology right and want to drive prices down like FedEx did back in the '70s for overnight deliveries.
Why not start with high value items --items where cost of delivery is a small fraction of the value of the good. Like FedEx did? Why go after groceries and perishables? It's an odd choice.
This is akin to Musk choosing Titan over Mars to explore the feasibility of interplanetary colonization by people.
[1]http://smallbusiness.chron.com/industry-standard-gross-margin-groceries-38121.html http://smallbusiness.chron.com/industry-standard-gross-margi...
- TheCoelacanth 10y agoTo deliver something in an hour, you have to be storing it very close to where you are going to deliver it. With low value items, it is practical to do that. With high value items, the cost of doing that would be prohibitive.
- mc32 10y agoSo, for many of these items Google does not have Google warehouses full of the things. They can partner with high value item sellers like they do with these low value items. They are not incurring the costs of warehousing and parked money.
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoIf the drone is a lower-cost delivery mechanism, then it has the greatest impact on low-margin items. Tablets can afford FedEx. Lettuce can't.
- mc32 10y agoDoesn't that aid my point? Why did they choose to try to prove same day delivery with items which cannot sustain the cost of deliveries (yet) given current technology. Why not prove the concept with higher value items and then move down the chain --as FedEx did. This approach seems a bit backwards to me.
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoNo, I don't think it aids your point. Let's say I can deliver it (for whatever "it" is) $1 cheaper with a drone than with a truck. Let's say I'm delivering a $300 tablet. Nobody cares about the $1. (I mean, yes, some business - either the seller or the delivery business - cares about the $1. But it's not enough to move the needle on customer behavior. If it would, a reasonably smart seller would drop their price $1.) But if I'm delivering a head of lettuce, that $1 difference is going to make significantly more customers have lettuce delivered. And the seller can't drop their price $1 to achieve the same effect, because they have 1% margin. More: If the seller lowers the price 98 cents and keeps 2 cents, the seller just doubled their margin on that head of lettuce. I think your point is also valid - working from the top of the value chain down is a fine strategy, and FedEx is a great example of it. But working from the bottom up ("disrupting from below") is also a very useful strategy, and Intel is a good example of it. They started making chips to power calculators. They didn't start by trying to replace IBM mainframes.
- mc32 10y agoThere is the interesting success of dabbawallahs who while operating on small margins while delivering perishable and time sensitive goods, do make a profit. So, in some circumstances success can be achieved, if it solves a problem that does not have an easy solution (in this case "home cooked" meals delivered to the workplace, but this has a cultural aspect to it and not sure how well it would translate to other items).