4 ms·
In general I like Electron, it makes it easy for web developers like me to get into making desktop apps. However, if you're not building it cross-platform, what
by diggan 10y ago
In general I like Electron, it makes it easy for web developers like me to get into making desktop apps. However, if you're not building it cross-platform, what's the benefit of Electron? If you disregard easy for web-developers.
- kilian 10y agoThis frustrates me a lot too. Whenever I encounter non-crossplatform Electron apps, I extract the mac or windows app.asar files and so far, all of them have ran fine on Ubuntu. That means it's just a matter of not taking the effort to package the app for multiple platforms. I get that packaging is not the most exciting part of application building, but it's not rocket science either. If anyone has an Electron app and wants/needs help with cross-platform packaging, feel free to contact me.
- 720kb 10y agoHi, have a look here later https://github.com/720kb/ndm#faq https://github.com/720kb/ndm#faq "As soon as we are sure that the project is stable, it will be delivered to the other OSs." :)
- tommoor 10y agoWhy do you disregard one of it's main benefits? MacOS development is notoriously tricky, so to enable it for the largest class of developers today makes a lot of sense. The other big advantage would be speed of iteration - particularly in a startup environment, being able to iterate on designs, layouts and functionality fast is a huge plus of working in JavaScript / HTML over native constructs.
- 720kb 10y agoAgree thanks :)
- bpicolo 10y agoI mean, web tech is more straightforward to work with / easier to find information on than desktop app platforms in general.
- 720kb 10y agoYes, is a different approach and has pro and cons.
- bluejekyll 10y agoLet's flip this around, what are the benefits of writing a native app when there is Electron? It's democratizing cross-platform Dev tools in one of the most standard rich environments, the browser. IMO, the question should always be, why native?
- untog 10y ago> Let's flip this around, what are the benefits of writing a native app when there is Electron? - Speed - Native UI - Native OS hooks
- bluejekyll 10y agoIMO those are specific choices for specific types of applications, when most people just need a simple front end for their app.
- eivarv 10y agoWhat about the energy performance hit that electron apps introduce?
- bluejekyll 10y agoI haven't noticed it, and use Atom (Electron based) on a Laptop often. It's a MacBookPro, so already one of the better in terms of battery consumption, but I use it disconnected from Power for upwards of 5-6 hours at a time with no issues.
- charrondev 10y ago> Speed I'll give you that, but performance is not the most important factor for most users of most applications. > Native UI Coming from someone who has done web development and iOS development, who tried native development for osx then switched to electron with react and redux, I have found it faster and easier to completely recreate the look and feel of the native osx views while adding custom functionality than to add custom functionality to natively. Appkit sucks and many of the improvements they've made over the years are only available in recent osx versions. The development experience is much better using VSCode than Xcode too. That's insane. A 2-3 year old web based text editor should not be a better, faster, and more stable development environment than the 8th version of the of the IDE from the most valuable company on the planet.