3 ms·
I dislike broadly-worded mostly-unenforceable laws and contract provisions almost more than plain bad laws and contracts, because then instead of pleasing a law
by nitrogen 17y ago
I dislike broadly-worded mostly-unenforceable laws and contract provisions almost more than plain bad laws and contracts, because then instead of pleasing a law, you have to worry about pleasing whoever is in charge of enforcing the law. If the enforcers don't like you, they can find something you're doing wrong and charge you with it/sue you for it.
So, what's not troubling to me is not the possibility of MPEG-LA suing everybody, but rather just suing people and companies they don't like (i.e. competitors, detractors, etc.), since virtually everybody making a corporate training video with an H264-based camera is violating the camera's H264 license.
- GHFigs 17y agorather just suing people and companies they don't like This is what the "non-discriminatory" part of the "reasonable and non-discriminatory" licensing terms that ISO/ITU require of their participating members is about.
- ZeroGravitas 17y agoClearly that's not true. They do sue people (they list them on their website) and yet, as discussed here, they don't sue everyone who breaks the ridiculously over-broad terms. That implies a choice. Then how do they discriminate here? I don't know, but it's not dictated by RAND terms which are often not reasonable either. Currently they also discriminate against smaller companies due to yearly caps on fees, and discriminate against certain business models e.g. subscription TV pays distribution fees, ad supported Hulu doesn't. That last one is clearly a decision made to mess with competition in a market with fewer barriers to entry while cementing lock-in in other areas.