3 ms·
No. No matter what the state of the environment, a mental illness is not going to improve the situation, if only because it limits the ability to change the env
by mcguire 10y ago
No. No matter what the state of the environment, a mental illness is not going to improve the situation, if only because it limits the ability to change the environment. In fact, that is the definition of mental illness: it causes problems in dealing with life.
A "healthy" mind in a dysfunctional environment can produce physical symptoms that mimic mental illness---anxiety for example---which makes diagnosis difficult, and is the root of the difference between the blues and clinical depression.
- wu-ikkyu 10y ago>A "healthy" mind in a dysfunctional environment can produce physical symptoms that mimic mental illness Im not sure I understand. When you say "mimic mental illness", are you saying that environmental factors cannot cause a "healthy" mind to get a "real" mental illness?
- mcguire 10y agoI have no solid data on that and I am not a mental health practitioner in any sense. But to my mind, no. The problems of a healthy mind in an unhealthy environment are easy to solve: change the environment and the problem goes away. On the other hand, problems such as my depression get only temporary relief from changing the environment; the only long term relief has been drug treatment.